Overall a very good experience
Overall a very good experience, however, the wrong SKU was shipped. The one I received was nice, actually heavier, but not the one I checked out with online.
By Tim R.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses

The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
396 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
The Fossil Exchange specializes in recovering and selling the highest quality Megalodon teeth and other prehistoric fossils from the Depths of the Atlantic Ocean. to hold a 5.6 Million year old tooth from the largest predator the world has ever known (Carcharocles Megalodon) is an experience like no other. Our Megalodon teeth and fossils come straight from the source, from the depths of the Atlantic Ocean to you! You can rest assured that every Megalodon Tooth we sell is 100 percent real, and recovered by us. We have a huge selction of fossils ranging from affordable Megalodon Teeth all the way up to the highest quality specimens in the world. Our divers have a wealth of knowledge, and are always willing to help you choose the perfect fossi
The Fossil Exchange (thefossilexchange.com) has 396 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
Showing 10 reviews with 4 stars · Clear filters
Overall a very good experience, however, the wrong SKU was shipped. The one I received was nice, actually heavier, but not the one I checked out with online.
By Tim R.
The Megaladon tooth that I ordered was exactly as represented and shipped in a timely manner. The only reason that I rated this a four, is that I thought that it would include a certificate of authenticity. I will be a returning customer.
By Brad D. W.
Chris, co-owner assisted me in the best possible way despite the fact that UPS didn't know how to clear the item.Finally, after 10 days I received my item in perfect condition. Many thanks Chris for your kind assistance. Best regards, Rudi.
By RUDI VAN U.
Product was as advertised, packaging was great. Paid for expedited shipping but delivery was still a little slow considering I’m only a couple of states away. Might be usps fault rather than the retailer tho.
By Aaron L.
The fossil is amazing. The only bad thing is that I had to pay an extra fee to the shipping service in Spain (correos) to get the fossil.
By David Soriano F.
The tooth was in great condition and as large as advertised. It was handle quickly and a young boy was extremely proud and happy with it. Only thought for improvement the Stand was a little small for the size and weight. Shout it would be worth to pay another $5 to have a nicer stand instead of looking for a different one.
By KR W.
Awesome specimens, better than anticipated
By Shawn N.
quite pleased with quality and fast shipping
By joey P.