I received the iced cookies from Sugar…
I received the iced cookies from Sugar Wish the cookie was soft but the icing was hard as a rock and didn’t taste fresh at all. Would prefer Cheryl’s cookies over these any day.
By Brenda
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses

The Fair Hearing score
Great
164 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Sugarwish is a female-founded gifting company that flipped the gifting model based on the idea that the receiver choosing their own gift was a more fun and memorable gift experience!Ideal for employee appreciation, client thank-you's, and holiday gifting needs. This not only makes it fun for them but also guarantees they receive something they genuinely love.
Sugarwish (sugarwish.com) has 164 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.1 out of 5.
164 approved reviews, newest moderated first
I received the iced cookies from Sugar Wish the cookie was soft but the icing was hard as a rock and didn’t taste fresh at all. Would prefer Cheryl’s cookies over these any day.
By Brenda
More packaging than cookies
By Jason T.
Response from Sugarwish· Mar 19, 2025
We truly appreciate your feedback! Our goal is to deliver happiness in every bite—and every box. Please reach out to our support team at [email protected] so we can send you a fresh batch of cookies. And just a note—our boxes are 100% recyclable because we believe in spreading joy while caring for the planet.
Sugarwish is the ultimate feel-good gift! You pick the gift, they pick their faves—candy, cookies, popcorn, coffee, and more—and it ships crazy fast! The packaging is adorable, the treats are top-notch, and it feels so personal. Perfect for birthdays, thank-yous, or just because. Seriously, it’s the easiest way to make someone’s day!
By Danielle S.
We ordered 200 boxes for our clients and all of them arrived fresh and delicious!! Our clients raved about their experience with the ease of ordering, the options available, and how fresh they were. We will be using Sugar Wish for all our client gifts. I even received this text last night "Thanks a lot, because of you I’m craving those damn brownies from sugar wish 🤣"
By Mariah Z.
This place is the best good ppl good vibes the place was just awesome
By customer
Cookies are dried out and terrible. I feel like we were punked. $80 worth of cookies.
By Dustin M.
I received my cookies in 6 days. They were stale and even the microwave couldn’t revive them. (According to the instructions) The please eat within 5 days is a joke when they’re stale on receipt. I’m very disappointed.
By Robin S.
Working with Sugarwish has been an absolutely fantastic experience. The product is high quality, the presentation is beautiful, and the customer service is excellent. I used their services to send gifts to my team members, and it was worth every penny. Highly recommend.
By TR H.