Tuesday, November 10, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Bad
120 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Officially Licensed Fan Gear From Sports Fan Island! NFL Fidget Spinners, MLB Team Fidget Spinners & Brxlz, MLB Canvas Shoes, Clear NFL Bags, NFL Spinners
Sports Fan Island (sportsfanisland.com) has 120 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 1.7 out of 5.
120 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Terrible Company. I ordered a number of things prior to Christmas. Some arrived but others were not in the shipment. I tried emailing the company 6 times since and did not get a response until a month later. But still no refund or products. They do not have a phone number or way to contact them other than email. Do not buy from this Company.
By James
I ordered Christmas presents from this company on December 9th. It's now January 16th and the order was not received. I have sent three emails to them asking for a refund, and NO RESPONSE. Horrible customer service. Avoid these scammers there are legit sports stores to order from. I learned my lesson.
By Cynthia K.
I placed an order. The payment was taken out of my account immediately. I received a notice that my items were on their way. The tracking states that a label was printed. FedEx has not received anything in regards to my order. I have emailed the company several times with no response. There is no phone number to contact anyone. I will never order again
By Jamie G.
Sent me the wrong item and expect me to return it before they send me the correct item ordered It is their fault, not mine. And then they want me to also send a payment just so that I can talk to someone, ARE YOU KIDDING ME!!! Just send me the correct item and then you get your returned item
By Rick H.
I ordered from this company never got my shoes. Tried emailing them over 6 times the will not answer. They basically stole my money. Don’t order from them scammers.
By Sheila S.
I have emailed the 3 times at this point. They lied on their website about Christmas shipping. Now I am trying to return the item because the order arrived way later them expected. It’s radio silence when it comes to their customer service. NEVER AGAIN will I purchase from them. I’ll be calling my bank today and taking further action.
By Victoria
I Definitely didn’t read any reviews. Wish I would have.. I just ordered from them and they changed a product I ordered to something else without saying a word.. This is crazy and with it being the holidays it’s going to take for ever to get this situation resolved. I will not be ordering from them ever again..
By Kianna M.
Imposing a fee to customers due to shoplifter is not a good idea. Why should customers be punished. Also if you have someone coming to store with knife to shoplift I would get armed security not put loss on customers. I know I won't buy anything because of this ridiculous fee and you putting in news.
By Kim G.
