Love the peanut butter cookies
Love the peanut butter cookies
By MaryLisa G.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
242 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We help customers find nutritious and indulgent food that will help them on their journey to a healthy lifestyle. Whether you're looking to lose weight or simply maintain a healthy diet, our products fit a busy lifestyle with great taste and affordability in mind.
Smart for Life (smartforlife.com) has 242 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
242 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Love the peanut butter cookies
By MaryLisa G.
When I was 50 I needed to lose 45 lbs and I loved this “diet” and lost the weight and had tons of energy. It only took 3 months and I followed it to the T Now I am 60 and need to lose some weight again and I’m doing the Smart for Life Cookies. Feeling great and losing the weight.
By Gonavy27
Great products that really work!
By Andrew
Thank for everything. I have used your cookie diet in the past and it worked good so I'm ordering from you again.
By Douglas E.
have used these products for years, THEY WORK. Just follow the program, food is good and healthy
By Cynthia D.
I really like the products. The amount of fiber, carbs and protein is a good ratio for me because I am very sensitive to carbs. To many carbs triggers into a overeating food binge and so I have to be careful. I also like the taste of the products. I haven't come across any one product that I haven't liked.Smart for life products work for me.
By Essie
So disappointed.There is flavor but the cookie even after microwaving was crumbly and dry. Flavored cardboard. Seriously, I couldn't swallow them and I wanted to so much. Also I ordered a different flavor than was sent to me. I called customer service within the 3 day time limit to return my 3 week order ($129.00) and was told it would be $75 restocking fee plus shipping (heavy box) to return because of the expiration date. It took a week and a half to receive the cookies and I could not find an expiration date on the cookies. Bottom line is that that I question the positive reviews I relied on about these cookies. Buyer beware. I will not be returning the cookies as there will not be enough money saved to bother. I really wanted this to work but have lost $129.00 in the process.
By Christy
Response from Smart for Life· Jun 5, 2018
Hello Christy, we're sorry you did not enjoy the cookies. They are consistently rated some of the best tasting healthy cookies on the market. They taste nothing like cardboard. Also, our review system is run by Trustpilot, an authority in ecommerce store reviews. Each review has to come from a verified order number - so I can assure you the hundreds of reviews we have are 100% real. Please contact Trustpilot if you have any further questions.
I went on this diet 3 years ago and lost 10 lbs in 2 weeks. I never put it back on because it taught me a better way to eat. Now I am back on it to lose another 5-10 lbs and reach my goal weight.
By Cofi J.