Get 2-3sizes larger than want
Get 2-3sizes larger than want. Mine is beautiful but very tight and I ordered a xl and fits like a medium...shirt is nice just size sucks.
By hope K.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
339 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Shirts By Sarah is a small family owned business in upstate NY. Feel good about your purchase! Our custom printed novelty t shirts are hand made by our family for yours. We started printing t-shirts in 2012 and have been loving it ever since.
Shirts By Sarah (shirtsbysarah.com) has 339 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
Showing 14 reviews with 4 stars · Clear filters
Get 2-3sizes larger than want. Mine is beautiful but very tight and I ordered a xl and fits like a medium...shirt is nice just size sucks.
By hope K.
Shirt looks great and fits well!! Fast shipping!! I would definitely order again!!
By Dawn
I prefer the silkscreen method to the iron on method. Do you make any silkscreened t shirts? 100% cotton preferred. Thanks!
By Nicki
Response from Shirts By Sarah· Jun 8, 2020
Hi Nicki! Our shirts are actually direct to garment printed which we find over time, is superior to screen printing. Right now, that's the only method we use to decorate our t-shirts. We hope you love your new shirt. Thank you for your business! -Sarah
The fabric is soft & the decal is good quality, not stiff or faded. It didn't shrink like the site said it would, so it is a bit large for me, but not a problem.
By brenda M.
Awesome Tshirt
By YOHANNA S.
I was so pleased to see a great Ally design, thank you ! It surprised me that the men’s did not come in purple as that is a standard lgbtq colour and I suspect that a lot of your customers ordering the ally shirt for friends would be gay ! Good success to you !
By gail C.
shirt arrived in mail earlier then expected, in perfect condition & neatly packaged, Shirts were a little small for stated size, so order up 1 size if you like it a bit loose.
By Chris M.
Very soft cotton, which thinner than I thought, but good for the hot summer.
By Mimi S.