Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
19 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Welcome to SellOldMagazines.comWe offer a unique service dedicated to purchasing old magazine collections. If you're looking to declutter, manage an estate, or free up space, we provide a seamless, efficient process for you to send us your vintage magazines.How Our Service Works1. Collection SubmissionSubmit details about your magazine collection through our platform. We review each submission to see if it aligns with our needs.2. Shipping Made EasyFor collections we're interested in, we'll send you a prepaid shipping label. There are no shipping costs for you.3. Receive Your PaymentAfter we receive and verify your magazines, we issue your payment promptly, ensuring a smooth transaction.Why Sell to Us?- *Hassle-Free Experience:* We simplify the selling process, handling all the details so you don't have to.- *Eco-Conscious:* Rehoming your magazines contributes to minimizing waste and sharing knowledge.- *Prompt Payment:* We prioritize swift transactions to ensure you receive your payment quickly.Ready to clear out your old magazines? Visit SellOldMagazines.com. Let us help you with a hassle-free way to pass on your collection, knowing it will find a new audience.
Selloldmagazines (selloldmagazines.com) has 19 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
19 approved reviews, newest moderated first
AJ was great to work with! I am clueless about magazines and had inherited a bunch of old ones. He was quick to respond with which magazines had value and which ones where fan fiction and not of any value. We had an email conversation and off went a chunk of the magazines. It was a quick process that helped clear out a large box taking up space in my house!
By Leandra E.
I dealt with AJ who was very responsive to my inquiries and was easy to work with. I was very pleased with the offer and was able to conclude our transaction with zero issues.
By Richard R.
100% recommend this business!! I am always skeptical of online businesses but this business is great! We cleared out Mother in laws estate and found old vintage magazines and catalogs from the 70’s. We didn't want to sell on our own but also didn’t want to just throw them away. I researched and felt comfortable trying Sell Old Magazines. Their response was so quick. I sent pictures and they made an offer that we felt was very fair. I packaged and got the weight and measurements and they sent prepaid shipping label. They paid me by Venmo the minute the package was received. So very appreciative of AJ at Sell Old Magazines!! THANK YOU!!!
By S. G.
The response to my inital email was prompt, they gave me a generous offer, shipping was easy, and payment was quick. A very good experience.
By K M.
Believe the rave reviews! This is one of the best businesses I've ever dealt with online.
By T.G.
My experience with AJ was absolutely outstanding! His offer to purchase my magazines was more than fair, and he was both professional and transparent in all aspects of our transaction. In short, he was a delight to work with, and I would highly recommend AJ!
By Seve G.
Their process was easy to use and I received a fair offer. I plan working with them again!
By Steve
Quick response, fair offer, easy completion. I couldn’t ask for a better way to get my old magazines to someone who can put them to good use.
By Barbara B.
