Sage JewelersReviews of sagejewelers.com

1112 Tilton Road, Northfield, New Jersey

Write a review Call Directions Website

The Fair Hearing score

4.9/ 5

Excellent

74 reviews

Sage Jewelers4.9Excellent

Write a review

Rating distribution

Select a line to read only those reviews.

What customers rate

Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.

About Sage Jewelers

Sage Jewelers is a progressively expanding, full-service, independent jewelry store. In business since 1980, our reputation is well known throughout the region.Our highly trained professional staff is courteous, caring, and competent. With two highly qualified jewelers on the premises with more than 80 years of combined experience, most of your repair needs can be completed in less than a week. Our Rolex certified watchmaker is capable of repairing practically all makes and models. We also specialize in custom jewelry and remounts using either your diamonds and gemstones or supplying high quality matching gems.

Sage Jewelers (sagejewelers.com) has 74 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.

Also known as: sagejewelers.com
Website: sagejewelers.com
Category: Jewelry & Watches
Location: Northfield, New Jersey
Listed on The Fair Hearing: 2026

More in Jewelry & Watches, New Jersey

Write a review

Feb 26, 2026

If I could give this review 0 stars I…

If I could give this review 0 stars I would. I ordered a watch online for a gift. I was told days later that my address was wrong because I didn’t have an apartment number. Because guess what? I don’t live in an apartment. I called to verify this information as soon as they opened the very next day and was told that Victor who handles online sales was out and would get back to me. After 3 days of me calling Victor told me that the watch had been sold already and there was nothing they can do. So I paid for a watch that should have been removed from the sales floor instead they collected money and left it on display for sale. I have a huge problem with that. There was no accountability and honestly gives the company a horrible reputation. The birthday is tomorrow and it left me with no time to replace the item. They didn’t even have the decency to call me to tell me they sold it.

By Unsatisfied C.

Response from Sage Jewelers· Mar 5, 2026

I want to respond clearly and factually so there’s no confusion about what happened. When the order was placed for the Pepsi watch, the shipping address came through as an apartment complex in the Bronx without an apartment number. Because of that, we could not ship the item. Victor called and left you a voicemail explaining that the payment information needed to be updated before we could proceed, and he also sent an email stating the same. In that message, he explained that the order would be refunded and the order would need to be placed again once the payment address was corrected. You later contacted one of our staff members and mentioned the address was off by one number and that you do not live in an apartment complex. However, a new order was not placed with the correct payment address information. Because the order remained incomplete and unprocessed, the watch was eventually purchased online by another customer. As you know, this particular Pepsi model is limited edition and high demand. When I spoke with you directly, I asked if you had received the voicemail, and you confirmed that you had. During our conversation there was no frustration expressed, and I offered to help you find another watch or contact you immediately if we receive another Pepsi in the future. I understand the disappointment, especially with a birthday involved. That part is unfortunate. But the order could not move forward without the required updates, and we did make attempts to communicate that. If you’d like us to keep an eye out for another Pepsi or help you select something comparable, we’re happy to do that.