Perfect fit.
Perfect fit.
By J S.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses

The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
105 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Our automotive rubber parts are exact reproductions and are made to standards that meet or exceed the originals. In addition to our 50+ restoration parts suppliers from across the country, we manufacture many rubber car parts here in our San Diego facility. We now offer a full line of rubber restoration parts for most American vehicles 1930+...windshield seals, door weatherstrips, beltline, window channels, rubber bumpers, grommets, odds & ends etc. Working closely with customers, friends, & parts books we meticulously reproduce every detail to make our parts the “right way.”
Rubber the Right Way INC (rubbertherightway.com) has 105 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
Showing 96 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Perfect fit.
By J S.
I own an auto body shop, and we were working on a 1977 Datsun. As we were replacing the tail lights, we came across seals that were old and cracked and we were only 3 days away from finishing it! I ordered 2 tail light seals and they got here with time to spare! The site was super easy to navigate, and the parts were well packaged. n my business, that is a very important factor!
By StoneMill C.
Had exactly what I needed at a reasonable price,and the team was very good about communicating as soon as I placed my order.
By Tony C.
The product is very good quality and the fit is perfect makes my old Dodge look well cared for.
By Dan P.
Made purchases multiple times always great service Great to talk to a live person Very knowledgeable and helpful getting the right part for the car Great quality and price
By joseph I.
I haven't had a chance to install the windshield on my '64 Bonneville yet, but I'm sure the parts are as great as the ones I bought for my '69 Galaxie
By NW F.
I had a problem with shipping but the company was very responsive to my issue and corrected it quickly.
By James Acri J.
Response from Rubber the Right Way INC· Jun 29, 2026
Hi James, I am so sorry for your experience with our company. You are 100% correct, $20 for shipping samples is ridiculous. While we are still not certain why this has happened we are looking into it. In the meantime we will issue a full refund for the sample order. Should you ever see anything from our company that doesn't seem right ; a part, fitment, price etc PLEASE reach out! We are super easy to work with and will do our best to resolve issues and make things right. Sincerely, Robert TEL: 866-789-7879 EMAIL: [email protected]
Good durable rubber. All hole pre punched and line up exactly. All push pins required to do install provided.
By Reggin H.
Response from Rubber the Right Way INC· Jul 10, 2026
Thank you for the review! Sincerely, Clayton 866-789-7879 www.RubberTheRightWay.com