Super easy, trustworthy.
Super easy. Very fair offers. Top notch communication. Top notch follow up. A+ experience
By John M.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
30 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Recast Fly Fishing is the most trusted source of high-quality used fly fishing gear for serious anglers. Everything we do is built around winning and keeping the trust of our customers. We buy and sell gear at a fair price, and provide detailed inspection videos, free shipping, and a money back guarantee.Recast Fly Fishing is proudly based in the Pacific Northwest, and calls the Yakima, Deschutes, Skagit, and Olympic Peninsula rivers our home waters.
Recastflyfishing (recastflyfishing.com) has 30 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
Showing 29 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Super easy. Very fair offers. Top notch communication. Top notch follow up. A+ experience
By John M.
I purchased a "used" Tibor Everglades and the reel was not only flawless, it was priced right. It appeared the reel had only been used a few times (if that) and there wasn't a scratch visible on it. Shipping was fast and secure and I was kept well informed with shipping information from the owner. He even sent some extra sasquatch stickers!
By Stephen M.
They kept in contact throughout the shipping process. Wonderful group to work with!!!
By Darrin S.
Response from Recastflyfishing· Apr 13, 2026
Thanks so much for the kind words.
Nice website, easy transaction, very fast shipping. Rod was just as described at a very fair price. Thanks!
By Khuong H.
Response from Recastflyfishing· Apr 1, 2026
Thanks so much for the kind words. Enjoy your new gear!
They were prompt in shipping. Product was delivered exactly as advertised
By Strat R.
Response from Recastflyfishing· Apr 1, 2026
Thanks so much for your kind feedback. We really appreciate your support.
I was looking for a great rod at a good price. The process was flawless and my rod arrived in great condition in 3 days.
By mark S.
Response from Recastflyfishing· Mar 11, 2026
Thanks so much for the kind feedback, Mark. Enjoy your new rod!
Seamless experience. Bought and sold a rod and Gordon was most helpful in guiding my purchase. Selling a rod was easy, no haggle, paid me what they said they would on the quote. Highly recomend dealing with ReCast Fly Fishing if you are in the market for a premium rod or reel but dont want to spend the high dollars on a new one.
By Bert P.
Response from Recastflyfishing· Mar 11, 2026
Thanks for the kind words, Bert. We really appreciate your support!
Rod is in fantastic shape. Easy transaction and fast shipping!
By Joe
Response from Recastflyfishing· Mar 11, 2026
Thanks Joe! We really appreciate your feedback. Enjoy your new rod!