Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
636 reviews
Pie InsuranceSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Pie Insurance provides workers’ compensation insurance directly to small businesses. Small business owners can now get a workers' comp quote in 3 minutes — which means getting coverage really is as easy as pie.
Pie Insurance (pieinsurance.com) has 636 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
636 approved reviews, newest moderated first
The most transparent and pleasant workers compensation audit experience.
By Cass
Response from Pie Insurance· Mar 3, 2021
Hi Cass, thanks for sharing such great feedback about your audit. We're so glad you're a Pie customer!
Danny went out of his way, above and beyond to help me. I think we became friends I called him so many time's.
By Pamela T.
Response from Pie Insurance· Feb 19, 2021
Hi Pamela, we love hearing how helpful Danny was! Thanks for writing such a great review.
Received a mailing and decided to get a quote. Company save me approximately $600 a year for same/better coverage.
By Menchies R.
Response from Pie Insurance· Feb 17, 2021
Hi there, thank you for leaving a great review! We're so happy to hear you saved with Pie.
Don't use them. I can't believe after I had been to this bad experience. I have told them that all partner will not include or file any claim. after that we got for audit next year $1900+. In addition, we sign the exclusion form and do electronic sign form. I have my complete sign copy and they said they have not receive. it.... I don't know if this is scam?
By Somkiet S.
Response from Pie Insurance· Jan 14, 2021
Hi Somkiet, we’re very sorry your experience with Pie did not meet your expectations. We’ve reached out to you a couple of times to find a solution. Please feel free to give us a call so we can resolve any concerns you have.
Helped me get what I needed very quickly
By Franklin C.
Response from Pie Insurance· Dec 28, 2020
Franklin, we love to hear it! Thanks for choosing Pie.
We had a great experience through our audit process. It can be un nerving making sure you have all the correct information together but we were told what to send in, then given opportunity to submit additional information if it was needed. The auditor was good at explaining what she needed and why and was very timely and professional.
By Pioneer A.
Response from Pie Insurance· Dec 28, 2020
Hi there - thanks for the review! We're so glad you had a positive experience with Pie.
I was skeptical about a Workers Comp Insurance Company that I had never heard of and was advertising on line for customers. But, I had a need, and your company filled the void in a solid way. Your sales staff was excellent and very responsive, and after a couple of days of putting together the information I was convinced that PIE could do the job. Thanks for the seamless transition.
By John V.
Response from Pie Insurance· Dec 1, 2020
John - thank you for trusting us with your business. We appreciate the great review!
Great experience with the transfer of our policy. Aldo was very informative and walked us thru the whole process. Our policy premium was cut in half.
By Sherryn
Response from Pie Insurance· Nov 23, 2020
Sherryn, so glad you were able to save with Pie! We appreciate you taking the time to write us a great review.
