I received the tag and they left off…
I received the tag and they left off the address. The engraving was super fine. I could hardly read it. Metal was thin. You get what you pay for. Waste of money.
By Lisa
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
177 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Do you need to know where to buy pet tags for your dogs and cats? We understand that your pet means the world to you and keeping your favorite furry friend absolutely safe is at the top of your priorities. At OvernightPetTags.com, we care about your pets as much as you do. All too often, dogs and cats wander away, and millions of pets end up in shelters. It is unfortunate that about 90 percent of the pets without valid pet identification tags fail to make it back home. Losing a pet can be a very traumatic experience. With our high-quality pet tags, you will be able to rest easy knowing that your pet is always identifiable and you are just a phone call away.
Overnightpettags (overnightpettags.com) has 177 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.6 out of 5.
Showing 8 reviews with 2 stars · Clear filters
I received the tag and they left off the address. The engraving was super fine. I could hardly read it. Metal was thin. You get what you pay for. Waste of money.
By Lisa
tiny print cannot read it even with glasses
By JO
Proofreading and customer service improvement needed - The last digit of my phone number was missing from the tag I ordered (the info provided to them was correct). Took 3 emails to get a response and over 2 weeks to get the corrected tag.
By Robin
Sent to the wrong address when ordered and paid for overnight delivery. Company did not offer any compensation or coupon. Very frustrating as we were moving and needed overnight. Tags also nothing special.
By GINGER G.
have collar on back order from dec havent received or heard a status
By DAWN H.
Tag was much bigger and of much poorer quality than expected
By V S.
Tags looked great but scratched so easily by the third day I could no longer read the name/phone engraved. Very disappointed.
By Pups M.
I placed an order on 8/7 and received part of it in a timeley fashion (the tags), however another item (the collars) was on backorder. I was not given an estimated date that it would be available (although I was still charged for them) and have emailed the OvernightPetTags TWICE to inquire about this with ZERO response.... Perhaps my review will grab their attention.
By Jaimielynn S.