Very simple McGivern diamonds will be…
Very simple McGivern diamonds will be the only jeweler I will ever use. Exceptional quality and service and price! Thanks Mike. Wayne C.
By Wayne C.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
254 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
McGivern Diamonds is listed under Jewelry & Watches in Perrysburg, Ohio.
McGivern Diamonds (overnightdiamonds.com) has 254 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
254 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Very simple McGivern diamonds will be the only jeweler I will ever use. Exceptional quality and service and price! Thanks Mike. Wayne C.
By Wayne C.
Michael McGivern handled my request and purchase personally. I’m living in Texas, making my purchase of diamond solitaire earrings for our 50th anniversary seamless. Earrings arrived on time and they were beautiful. You can’t find a better jeweler anywhere. Al K.
By Al K.
Mike and his entire staff were a pleasure to work with! Very responsive, thorough and always put my needs first. They are extremely trustworthy and strive to make your experience flawless. I would highly recommend them. Top notch service and quality!
By Jocelyn Z.
We had a positive experience custom-making my engagement ring, and we couldn't be happier with it. Mike answered all of our questions in detail and the ring was received in a timely manner. Highly recommended
By Michelle T.
Amazing service, fantastic quality!
By Lucas C.
Nice clean diamonds. This is my go to shop
By Jay
Mike was great to work with. I came in with an idea of what I wanted and Mike was able to tell exactly what I wanted and executed everything to perfection! My fiancé absolutely loved the ring Mike helped me pick out. Everything went smoothly and arrived to me on time. I would recommend McGivern Diamonds to anyone and everyone!
By Alexander P.
Highly recommend purchasing jewelry from McGivern’s. To celebrate our anniversary, we started looking online at all the beautiful stones for a new ring. Mike helped us design an exquisite custom ring. The overall experience was seamless. The delivery from Ohio to another state was timely, secure, and safe. We plan to purchase jewelry here going forward. The ring is exactly what I envisioned and more.
By Maura