Very professional
Very professional, great eye for grades that are more than fair to customers. A pleasure to do business with!
By DJ A.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
254 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
McGivern Diamonds is listed under Jewelry & Watches in Perrysburg, Ohio.
McGivern Diamonds (overnightdiamonds.com) has 254 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
254 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Very professional, great eye for grades that are more than fair to customers. A pleasure to do business with!
By DJ A.
When my husband proposed 10+ years ago, I told him I didn't need an expensive diamond or anything fancy, but he quietly did a lot of research and then purchased my engagement ring and our wedding bands from McGiven by phone. (We're in Colorado.) To this day, I love it!!! It's classical simplicity, kind of like me, and it's beautiful. I had no idea how special a great, quality diamond can make you feel. And having seen the comparisons to other diamonds available at retail and online stores, the price value and quality from McGiven was outstanding, as was the excellent purchasing experience. Thank you!
By Amy V.
I recently had a custom ring done by McGivern's and it turned out exactly how I wanted it. They did a wonderful job and, at, what I considered to be a fair price.
By Lori
Great service and product
By Frank
Couldn't be more pleased with the customer service, "aim-to-please" attitude and caliber of the diamonds and custom jewelry service at McGivern Diamonds. Highly recommend them~
By Laurie Melchior H.
Awesome! Ring is beautiful and exactly as described. Michael was a pleasure to work with throughout the process. Always responded to questions immediately. Would definitely do business with him again!
By Cheryl A.
Mike treated me like he was my personal jewelry assistant, and I do not personally know him. Great at responding to emails. Very competitive pricing. My engagement ring was 1) created as agreed upon, and 2) delivered on time. And it looks great! Initially hesitant paying first before getting the engagement ring, but it was worth it.
By Chad E.
Very professional, creative suggestions and very accommodating on changes during the design process! Final product is perfect!
By Mike K.