Sunday, November 8, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
100 reviews
Olive Oil JonesSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Olive Oil Jones is seven different early-harvest unfiltered olive oils. Same growers, same labor, same mills as last season and the year before. OOJ imports huge barrels of these oils from Italy, Spain and Portugal to its South Bronx warehouse. This is where we pump and pack hand-bottled oils when your order comes in. We are old-school; no oil is pre-bottled. We are hands on. Our oils are waiting for you, billowing with fragrance and freshness. We also import and sell select vinegars from Italy and Spain that are made by small companies that specialize in artisanal products and that we want to use ourselves. The coffee we import from Sicily is slow roasted, rich and has a seductive aroma.
Olive Oil Jones (oliveoiljones.com) has 100 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5.
100 approved reviews, newest moderated first
The unusual depth of flavor in the different olive oils we've ordered from them; the excellent customer service; and the personal tone in their communications -- you don't feel like you're buying from a big corporation.
By Bart from B.
High quality product! Amazing customer service. The olive oil is fabulous but I’m also a huge fan of their line of balsamic vinegars!
By robin H.
I was gifted a bottle of OOJ and then I was hooked! We've tried a variety of oils and love them all. Don't miss out on the marcona almonds either:)
By Gary G.
I was fortunate to read a New York Times article 4-5 years ago regarding Steve and Michelle starting a new import business with ultra premium olive oils and vinegars. Their products "blew me away" as by far the best I have ever tasted. I have been to Europe many times and never tested oils and saba as delicious as theirs. Their customer service and ordering process is seamless and efficient as Amazon Prime. On one of my numerous orders and bottle of saba leaked and turned the entire shipping carton into a wet mess. After a quick email an entire new order was shipped including an extra bottle for my inconvenience. I only pray they never go out of business as my taste buds could never settle for anything less than their olive oil and saba perfection.
By JB
Oils and vinegars are top quality and delicious. I order them for myself as as gifts for family and friends. Can’t beat the marcona almonds either. Net greasy and freeze well for future use!!
By Jan
The Oils are awesome! So fresh and makes me feel like I'm back in Italy.
By Dini G.
The very freshest and best olive oil delivered so fast you never run out of olive oil. It's almost like having an olive press on the next block! Been addicted to their oils and vinegars for at least 2 years when I complained to my daughter that I couldn't find great lambrusco vinegar in my local market anymore & she looked online and discovered Olive Oil Jones. Now I order a couple of bottles of oil and vinegar at a time so I always have it on hand. Western Sicilian has become my favorite. ( I honestly don't remember when I ordered last but I just finished a large bottle & was going to order today when I saw the review email.)
By Loraine B.
The sampler of olive oils really is a life-changer, the oils are so fresh and so full of individual character! Who knew? (Well, of course, you guys do!)
By David R.
