New Yorker BagelsReviews of newyorkerbagels.com

The Fair Hearing score

2.3/ 5

Poor

28 reviews

New Yorker Bagels2.3Poor

Rating distribution

Select a line to read only those reviews.

Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.

World's largest baker of hand-rolled New York City bagels, shipped fresh overnight. Kosher with Free Overnight Shipping.

New Yorker Bagels (newyorkerbagels.com) has 28 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 2.3 out of 5.

28 approved reviews, newest moderated first

May 13, 2024
More “bread-like” than “bagel-like”
More “bread-like” than “bagel-like”. These are not at all like NY Bagels…
By Adam C.
Nov 8, 2023
No Prize Winner
Believing we could find the ideal bagel with the 1st ingredient-Whole Wheat-we ordered a dozen (everything) at just under $40.00, shipping included special. They're much bigger than regular bagels. This may suit those with mega appetites. However, we found-even after toasting-extremely soft to the bite. The lack of crunch, apparently lending to the ingredient mix is most unfortunate. The palpable taste of sodium @ 460mg is too much and steals the overall taste.
By HL
Mar 1, 2023
I ordered 6 Bialys and 6 Onion Bagels
I ordered 6 Bialys and 6 Onion Bagels, and Neither had a chew, Both were small. The bialys had no onions or poppy seeds. The taste left you wanting. It you would like to be disappointed by all means order some. Ill just wait until next time I am in NY to get some I suppose. For what these people charge they could do it right. Sad
By M R.
May 6, 2022
Best bagel ever!
Best bagel ever!
By Tom L.