Sunday, November 8, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
68 reviews
Mr. SteakSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Mr. Steak delivers steak house quality meats right to your door & quality infrared grills that make those meats stand out.
Mr. Steak (mrsteak.com) has 68 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.
Showing 59 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Probably one of the best meat boxes I’ve got
By Tyler
Response from Mr. Steak· Dec 16, 2020
Hey Tyler, Thanks so much for the positive review. We hope these steaks brightened up your summer. Please let us know if there is ever anything we can help with in the future. Thanks, James [email protected]
I read a review on Kitchn about Mr. Steak and was intrigued. After discussing it with my husband, I decided to give it a try... OMG!!! I wasn't disappointed! When my order arrived, it was packaged exactly as described on the website. Our box contained burgers, filets, strip steaks and a boneless ribeye. The craft brisket burgers were wonderful!! They were huge, juicy and packed so much flavor that minimal seasoning was required! The filet was absolutely the best we've ever had!! It literally melted in our mouths! We can't wait to try the rest of our box!!!
By Trina
Response from Mr. Steak· Jul 15, 2020
Hi Trina! Thank you so much for taking the time to write us this fantastic review!! We are so appreciative and are delighted to read how much you loved our brisket burgers and filets!! We hope you enjoyed the rest of your box and can't wait for you to try some of our other steaks in the future. Thanks again and happy grilling!! Liz Mr. Steak
So far, we’ve only had the 12 oz ribeye, which was delicious. I was surprised, however, to see that the thickness was not uniform across the steak. It tapered noticeably from one end to the other, preventing an even cook.
By Karen C.
Response from Mr. Steak· Mar 2, 2021
Hi Karen! Thanks so much for trying our 12oz ribeye! We hope you've had a chance to try some of our other steaks by now. We appreciate your note about the thickness. We've worked on this and I think you'll find an even thickness moving forward! Thanks for taking the time to write us a review and happy grilling! Liz
This is the best steak I've ever prepared at home. Cook it right and you won't be disappointed.
By Timothy Gus J.
Response from Mr. Steak· Dec 16, 2020
Hey Timothy, Thanks so much for taking the time to write your review! You sure said the magic words, "cook it right!" These are serious steaks and if you cook them right, you won't be disappointed. That's why Mr. Steak created his Ten Commandments of Steak. Send us some pics or video of you grilling some time and we'll post it. Grill on! James [email protected]
Everything went smoothly!
By Paige E.
Response from Mr. Steak· Dec 16, 2020
Hey Paige, Thanks so much for the review and letting us know it all went smooth. We hope you enjoyed your steaks! We really appreciate the recommendation. Please let us know if there is ever anything we can help with in the future. Thanks, James [email protected]
Easy to order, super fast delivery and very high quality meat. Will order again.
By Claire B.
Response from Mr. Steak· Mar 2, 2021
Hi Claire, We're so glad you enjoyed your meats and that the process was easy! We hope you're doing well and that you try us again soon! Thanks for leaving us a great review. :) Happy grilling, Liz Mr. Steak
Excellent meat, packaging, and service.
By Marilyn R.
Delicious meats, divine customer service!
By Carson W.
