Keystone was very professional and…
Keystone was very professional and courteous. He gave us all the medical information and instructions on how we can enjoy our new family member.
By Lance B.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
1,920 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Founded in 2012, Keystone Puppies is a small, family-owned company dedicated to helping families safely find healthy, well-socialized puppies from reputable dog breeders.We are a trusted online puppy advertising platform that connects responsible breeders with caring families searching for puppies for sale. Our goal is to provide a credible, transparent place where potential pet owners can confidently find their fur-ever companion without uncertainty or risk.At Keystone Puppies, we carefully partner with responsible dog breeders who raise their puppies in clean, nurturing environments and prioritize proper veterinary care, early socialization, and overall health. We believe that well-raised puppies transition more smoothly into their new homes, creating lifelong bonds between pets and families.Through our Accredited Breeder Program, we recognize breeders who go above and beyond state requirements. Accredited breeders offer extended health guarantees, follow higher care standards, and remain committed to continually improving their breeding practices. By incentivizing these higher standards, we work to elevate responsible breeding practices across the industry.As a family-owned business, relationships matter to us. We are hands-on, involved, and committed to transparency, accountability, and improving the experience of buying a puppy online. Families across the United States trust Keystone Puppies to connect them with reputable breeders and healthy puppies raised with care.Every puppy deserves a loving home. Every family deserves peace of mind. Keystone Puppies exists to make that connection possible....safely, responsibly, and confidently.
Keystone Puppies (keystonepuppies.com) has 1,920 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
1,920 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Keystone was very professional and courteous. He gave us all the medical information and instructions on how we can enjoy our new family member.
By Lance B.
the place we got the puppy was neat and clean and was like walking into a living room we bought the pup from Levi Glick and he asked if we had a fenced in yard for pup to run and play, Also ask if somebody would be with the pup to take care of it through the day a very neat and well run place
By customer
Response from Keystone Puppies· Mar 23, 2026
Thank you so much for your thoughtful review! We are so happy to hear that you had such a positive experience and that Levi took the time to ask about your home setup - that level of care means a lot. We appreciate you sharing your experience and wish you all the best with your new pup!
I AM SO HAPPY WITH MY PUPPY
By Yaskel D.
Super smooth experience. I called and within 3 days I had my new puppy. She’s exactly as advertised. Plus, Keystone was willing to arrange delivery but we ultimately chose to pick her up. Love my puppy.
By Rosemarie
SEAMLESS TRANSACTION
By customer JIM C.
it was the easiest web site to navigate clear cut information quick responds no long profiles or application; I am very happy with my baby Sophie she is malt/poo born December 3rd,2025. she three 1/2-month-old now and very smart she is potty training outside and is going very well and also thanks to my breeder John Stoltzfus and his wife are very friendly and just the best ever, I love my baby Sophie and so grateful she came into my life,,,,,, thanks eve
By eve
Response from Keystone Puppies· Mar 17, 2026
Thank you so much for sharing your experience! We’re so happy to hear that you found our website easy to navigate and that the process was quick and smooth for you! Sophie sounds absolutely wonderful! It’s so great to hear how smart she is and that potty training is already going so well. We’re also glad you had such a positive experience with John Stoltzfus and his family...they truly care about their puppies. Wishing you and Sophie many happy, love-filled years together. Thank you again for choosing Keystone Puppies!
Everything is excellent; the puppy is healthy.
By customer
We had a great experience with the entire process.
By LK