GREAT SHIPPING, "SALES" EEEH
GOOD MIDDLEMAN COMPANY, IN STOCK FAST SHIPPING. SALE PRICES NOT SO GREAT. RAINBOWS NEVER ON SALE
By DAVID S.
Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses

The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
784 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Islanders Coastal Outfitter is your source for surf & outdoor women's and men's shoes, accessories, apparel and gear. Our brands include Hari Mari, Rainbow, Reef, Olukai, UGG, KAVU and many others. We are lucky to call the beach our home since 1980.
Islanders Outfitter (islandersoutfitter.com) has 784 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.
784 approved reviews, newest moderated first
GOOD MIDDLEMAN COMPANY, IN STOCK FAST SHIPPING. SALE PRICES NOT SO GREAT. RAINBOWS NEVER ON SALE
By DAVID S.
Tried to return shoes that didn't fit well. When I asked what the procedure was to do that, I was told the shoes had to be essentially un-worn. Well, I obviously had to wear them around a bit to make sure that it wasn't just a "new show" feel. So, I couldn't return the shoes.
By Yash P.
Great first experience. Filled order quickly, shipped and received quickly. Will be ordering again. Thanks
By Brad
Hard to find these days, but IslandSurf did what they said they would do, delivered the correct item very fast, and were VERY easy to deal with! Highly recommend this company!
By Diana
My friend dropped my FAV rainbow flip flops in the ocean. They were lost 5ever. But he bought me a replacement pair and now we are friends again. <3 YAYAYAH!!!!! WOO HOO
By Chris
I ordered a pair of Birks and was pleasantly surprised when I received free 2-3 day shipping, my sandals came a few days later, the day before I left for a weekend at the coast which was perfect timing. I've been living in my Birks ever since. I will definitely be ordering from IslandSurf again.
By Alyssa T.
My family always returns to Islander's.
By Maureen T.
I needed 2 pairs of sandals as gifts for my husband's birthday. They only had them in 1 of the colors I needed, but they let me know when I could expect the second pair to become available. They were available the very next day and were immediately shipped out! I received both pairs on the same day and was able to give them both to my husband on his birthday. I was kept apprised of their delivery information with timely messenger emails. I found the entire shopping experience quick, efficient, friendly and satisfying. I will definitely shop with them again!
By Debra B.