Large selection on beautiful stones at…
Large selection of beautiful stones at every price point. Website is easy to navigate, communication about order and shipping superb.
By Karen P.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
175 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
GemsNY is a New Jersey based fine jewelry and gemstone retailer specializing in natural gemstones, diamonds, and beautifully crafted jewelry. With a commitment to quality, transparency, and customer satisfaction, GemsNY offers a wide selection of precious and semi-precious gemstones, including sapphires, rubies, emeralds, tanzanites, aquamarines, and many more.At GemsNY, customers can explore an extensive collection of loose gemstones, engagement rings, wedding bands, earrings, pendants, and other fine jewelry. Our customization options allow customers to create personalized pieces by selecting their preferred gemstones, settings, and designs.We believe that buying fine jewelry should be a transparent, enjoyable, and confident experience. That's why we focus on providing detailed product information, competitive pricing, and personalized customer support throughout the purchasing journey.Whether you're searching for a timeless engagement ring, a meaningful anniversary gift, a rare gemstone, or a unique piece of jewelry, GemsNY strives to make every purchase special.Our mission is to make exceptional gemstones and fine jewelry accessible while maintaining high standards of craftsmanship, authenticity, and service.Discover beautiful gemstones, create something uniquely yours, and shop with confidence at GemsNY.com, where quality, value, and personalization come together.
GemsNY (gemsny.com) has 175 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.
175 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Large selection of beautiful stones at every price point. Website is easy to navigate, communication about order and shipping superb.
By Karen P.
Online shopping is great, it would be helpful to be able to compare the size of the jewelry to a known item before placing the order. It would also be helpful to be able to specify getting a larger sizing on a bracelet. Good value!
By Kenneth
Beautiful pendant & great price! Thank You!
By Theresa K.
Product arrived in time and was exactly what we were expecting! I'll consider buying from them again!
By Gayelord P.
Sashel lee made our experience with Gemstone NY the best experience we have ever had with any sales person we could possibly have asked for RINGS WERE AND ARE STILL BEAUTIFUL THANK YOU
By Rex
What made the experience great was Saschel and the actual Ruby acquired and ring matching what I wanted. The updated GIA report was biggest selling point for me, and really made this a great acquisition. What could have been better was not getting the free earrings (which I specified I didn’t need), and preferred a pendent. But that was a free item and I’m not concerned.
By Michael
Beautiful earrings
By DD
Excellent customer service and great quality! I recommended GemsNY to a friend who loved my ring and asked where it was purchased. I actually purchased this ring in early 2025.
By Bernadette