Birthday cake disappointed
Received my order in a timely manner but was disappointed with the taste of the Birthday Cake Batter bars. Will not be ordering these again.
By David B.
Sunday, November 8, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
189 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Experience the Joy of Healthy Snacking20g ProteinGMO FreeGluten FreeNo Artificial SweetenersNo Artificial Flavors
FitJoy (fitjoynutrition.com) has 189 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5.
Showing 6 reviews with 3 stars · Clear filters
Received my order in a timely manner but was disappointed with the taste of the Birthday Cake Batter bars. Will not be ordering these again.
By David B.
I ordered CCCD and Brownie bars and received the CCCD in melted and then rehardened form (it is winter and not hot here). I asked to get new bars and have to take these melted/hardened bars back to FEDEX facility to mail back to get replacement bars. Rep said they have that issue with CCCD bars because they are the softest bar they sell. Seems hugely inconvenient to consumer just to get what they ordered in an edible form.
By Carolyn
Eaten on an empty stomach, bars made my stomach upset and I lacked energy, despite 20 g of protein in bar. Only after I had serving of trail mix did I feel better. This happened with first 5 flavors of bars. The only bar left to try is the frosted cinnamon.
By NeeNee
I liked the texture and added chunks but the flavor wasn't that great, didn't love the after taste but I liked the minimal ingredients and low net carbs
By Mel M.
Disappointed that sugar alcohol is not listed in the nutrition graphic. Bought these bars because the person at GNC said it did not contain sugar alcohol. Every other brand of protein bar has sugar alcohol listed separately from sugar. These bars are delicious, but I am very sensitive to sugar alcohol.
By Carol H.
Flavors were on par, however they were all very chewy.
By Evan G.