Not that impressed with odds on instant…
Not that impressed with odds on instant rips. Too predictable
By Dylan R.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
392 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
The official marketplace for sports trading cards, Pokémon, and collectibles.
Fanatics Collect (fanaticscollect.com) has 392 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.1 out of 5.
Showing 43 reviews with 2 stars · Clear filters
Not that impressed with odds on instant rips. Too predictable
By Dylan R.
Taking way too long to send the card to me. It's the 22nd and I clicked to send it to me on the 15th.
By Joshua E.
Over half of my collection is unable to be scanned or if it is scanned it’s a first time fine and unable to be added to my collection and also the support is not the greatest sadly hate to say that sorry but I still have not got purchases that I have made fixed as well as not being able to add the half of my collection that Fanatics has first time finds or does not respond to the first time finds so you just left without mailing in that card not added to the question gets old
By Corey F.
A $800+ should not be slipped loose and falling out of a penny sleeve. The offer of "here is enough fan cash to almost cover what you paid in shipping" was an okay gesture, I suppose, but seems inadequate
By David L.
I get this review 3 weeks after my order. I still have not received my card. Only reason it didnt get a 1 star is because it does say in transit now and I got at a good price. Just beware if you buy you will wait.
By Terry
Requested support on a shipment & nothing came of it. Still confused on the status even after reaching out.
By ben F.
I won an auction item and paid promptly the next day. It has been more than a week and my item still hasn’t shipped yet. This happened previously when I won an auction item as well, it took nearly two weeks for the item to ship.
By Jason K.
Response from Fanatics Collect· Oct 21, 2026
Hi Jason, thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We’re really sorry to hear this didn’t go the way it should have, this isn’t the standard we hold ourselves to. We’d love the opportunity to make this right. We have reached out to our team to ensure that your item is shipped today.
Not worth the price
By Airwreck
Response from Fanatics Collect· Oct 21, 2026
Hi Airwreck, thank you for the honest feedback, we appreciate you sharing the areas where we fell short. We’re always working to improve and your input helps.