Like that sent mock-up before…
Like that sent mock-up before completing order. Once approved item shipped and received timely. Looks great!
By Martha G.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
48 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Engrave My Wine is listed under Beer & Wine in Brooklyn, New York.
Engrave My Wine (engravemywine.com) has 48 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.
48 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Like that sent mock-up before completing order. Once approved item shipped and received timely. Looks great!
By Martha G.
Great experience! Fast shipping!
By Christina L.
I ordered an engraved bottle for an employee who just celebrated 25 years with our Company. I worked with the design team who was most helpful, fast and efficient. It turned out lovely and is a very unique gift. I would highly recommend them.
By Christine B.
Very need, a wonderful and original gift
By Miguel R.
Great gift . Excellent customer service ... Very fast delivery!!!!!
By Donna S.
the engraving was great and looked exactly like what I requested, similar to 2 years ago. Only issue was with bottle itself which had some marks/scratches that is clearly visible to naked eyes which was embarrassing when the gift was presented; and receiver pointing them out (twice!)
By Richard Y.
Perfect! I am in awe of how well my purchase turned out! I paid for the email proof which was well worth it. They emailed me throughout the whole process and even made suggestions that improved the look of my request. Not an up-sale! The recommendations didn’t cost anything more. The final product was beyond my expectations. Worth every penny for exactly what I wanted. It was packaged so carefully for shipping from N.J to Texas. Highly recommend!
By Shannon
Response from Engrave My Wine· Dec 15, 2025
You're Amazing!!! Thank you so much for your review 🙂 It's challenging to stand out in a crowded space, especially online. Our approach, since day one, has always been to help guide customers and to create the most beautiful personalized gifts. We love that you relied on our expertise and that exceeded your expectations. Sounds corny, but this review is what fuels our passion and keeps us going! You made my day and I speak for the team in saying so 😄 Thanks, again. - SZ
Although you have to pay extra for a preview of your item engrave, my wine, got back to us in less than 24 hours with the preview. It also was expeditiously shipped and arrived in less than a week from when the order was placed.
By Erae G.
Response from Engrave My Wine· Dec 15, 2025
You're Amazing! Thank you so much for your review 🙂