Awesome prank!
Awesome prank! I definitely plan to send more. Got a couple good laughs out of it. Customer service was really great too. Thanks for working with me!
By Jill
Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
518 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Anonymously mail a bag of dicks with the message "EAT A BAG OF DICKS".
Dicks By Mail (dicksbymail.com) has 518 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
518 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Awesome prank! I definitely plan to send more. Got a couple good laughs out of it. Customer service was really great too. Thanks for working with me!
By Jill
I have always had a great experience with this company, no problems in the past. Everyone has always gotten a laugh from their products, which taste surprisingly good. This time I messed up on the address I was shipping to and customer service was able to help me right away. Would definitely recommend.
By KS
Excellent customer service!
By Rachel
Ordered a chocolate dick and gummies. Never received a second email with the confirmation and tracking number. Attempted to reach out to them by email twice and have not gotten a response.
By Stephanie V.
I placed an order with this company and when I received it it wasn't packaged with the packaging that I had ordered. obviously I was upset because I had ordered it as a birthday gift and I got a Valentine's Day one instead . but customer service was great and immediately refunded my money kudos to them for making things right I will definitely be using the service again there's just something that tickles me pink about a dick in a box made of chocolate
By misty A.
Customer service is fantastic and these gifts are hilarious
By Chris M.
These guys rule I had made a serious mistake in the shipping address I reached out too them and had it corrected in no time thanks people for the great gift
By Ronnie F.
We ordered 8 of these for family and 2 the USPS messed up delivery. They resent new ones out to our family for us. Great customer service.
By Kimberly R.