Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
523 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Comp-Tac® Holsters is devoted to designing and manufacturing the highest quality concealed carry, competition, and tactical holsters on the market. We build with the customer in mind, ensuring fast delivery times, excellent quality, competitive pricing, and attentive customer service to support our community. We take each step of our manufacturing process very seriously, so we fit check every single holster with the actual firearm that it is designed for before it leaves our factory. Comp-Tac® products are user-driven and are designed based on the operational experiences of a wide variety of end users, to include military and law enforcement personnel. In 2018, High Speed Gear® purchased the Comp-Tac® brand and we are proud to be part of the High Speed Gear Products Group. Our holsters work seamlessly with HSGI® and together, our 2 brands offer exceptional quality and innovation that our customers trust and rely on.
Comp-Tac Holsters (comp-tac.com) has 523 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
523 approved reviews, newest moderated first
I have other brand but they just were not right. Switched to Comp Tac and never looked back. What I am disappointed with is you used send a package of candy with each holster. And this time I did not get my candy. Might have start looking elsewhere.
By Alexander R H.
Exactly as ordered and quick shipping
By Wayne L.
Worked with me to make sure what I got was what I wanted.
By Doug
I was really disappointed with this holster. The materials feel cheap, and the inside surface of the holster is rough, with small ridges that have nothing to do with matching the surface of the pistol. These will scrape on the slide and cause unnecessary wear. The rigidity of the polymer also means the paddle does not conform well to my shape, making it less comfortable than other paddle holsters I own. Lastly, I was really excited about the ability to use this holster both OWB & IWB, but I wanted to use it in the appendix position IWB. This isn’t possible because the front clip has to mount with either a positive or negative cant. There’s no means of setting it up for a straight draw. In the end, I will use this holster purely as a paddle OWB on training days when an OWB holster is all that is permitted. Otherwise, it will stay in the drawer with the other not-so-great holsters.
By Craig
Response from Comp-Tac Holsters· Jul 3, 2024
Good morning and thank you for your review! To achieve a neutral cant for AIWB you will want to use the bottom two holes in the 4-hole pattern in the front of the holster. Here is a link to a picture that might help: https://www.comp-tac.com/media/catalog/product/i/n/infidel_cant-tower.jpg?optimize=low&bg-color=255,255,255&fit=bounds&height=500&width=500&canvas=500:500 As far as the inside of the holster, it was molded to accommodate the aggressive slide cuts of the PDP - with anything, where two contact points are made there will be rubbing - but any slide wear should come off with a rag or pencil eraser. hope that helps!
I’m a long term Comp-Tac customer, and while what I got was not particularly exciting (a twin-mag carrier…I got it in gray so that’s pretty different), it does work well at keeping my magazines from rattling around. Will continue to check out Comp-Tac, but if anything is made available in “Banana yellow”, let me know
By Jason
I’m a fan as I have a few (6 to be exact) of these International model holsters I that I use to compete with. Simple and effective.
By Eddie C.
Very simple. Ordered holster (love the selection offered). Shipped and was at the house in a week. Always look to Comp-Tac whenever I need a new holster or mag carrier. My favorite company for these items!
By Nathan K.
All right, I ordered the wrong thing once and then I canceled it and then ordered the right thing and everything went great so thank you very much
By David
