great stuff works well and holds great …
great stuff works well and holds great easy directions and easy application
By Robert
Monday, November 2, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
314 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
At Colorsmith, we believe that when your hair color fits like a glove, you feel like your best self every day. Get ready for a new way to color, with everything you need delivered to your door in one discreet box.Led by a team of real-life colorists at our Los Angeles Headquarters, our custom men’s hair color and beard color takes into account your unique needs to give you a natural-looking finish. Similar to the salon experience, each bottle of hair color starts with a consultation. By taking our Quiz, our licensed colorists get to know you and your color goals before crafting a completely customized shade, made-to-order just for you. From the name on the bottle to the personalized instructions, we’re revolutionizing at-home hair color for men and taking things to the next level by giving you access to a personal colorist at every step along your color journey. Whether you want to adjust your hair dye or beard dye (our patented customization technology can adjust your color down to a ¼ of a shade) or want to learn how to get the best gray coverage, our professional colorists are here to help. In addition to our custom Color Case, we offer professional-grade hair care (like shampoos, conditioners, and stylers) and salon-inspired tools (like scalp massagers). Connect with a colorist today and start crafting your unique shade.
Colorsmith (colorsmith.co) has 314 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.0 out of 5.
314 approved reviews, newest moderated first
great stuff works well and holds great easy directions and easy application
By Robert
It’s not that different than all the rest and didn’t cover the grey any better.
By Tom D.
I followed the instructions to the letter and the dye didn’t change the colour of my beard. I also woke up with a major allergic reaction to it…it’s 2nd day of applying steroid cream and taking strong antihistamine to combat the side effects
By Mr T.
I don't really have anything to complain. I like the product end the customer team is very polite and risolutive.
By Ale
Colour didn't last 2 weeks (their website says it will last 4-6weeks) really disappointed with this. I wanted the dye to blend my beard in the chin area only (it was/is white whereas rest of beard was dark), got given a bottle that was big enough to do my whole head of hair; so it felt like I was paying for a quantity of product that was too much for my needs. Overall very disappointed with this product, I won't be using again
By Kevin R.
its a SCAM!!! Their product does not cover any grays even though i have colored twice at once i have cancelled my subscription straight away in may 2024 all of the sudden february 2025 they started to send me products without my consent they charged my account £24 i've tried to contact them and they were willing to pay money back (which cold be a lie) but i had to pay postal to send the product and im not going to because i haven't ask them to send it i have contacted the bank already and they will investigate and return the money Just 5 of the shelf works way better!!!
By Adam K.
Color match was perfect. Even my Barber was impressed. Orders are always on time and the process is thoroughly explained. Packaging is perfect size.
By Jesse E.
These are conmen. If you make a single payment with a debit/credit card, they will use those details to keep taking subsequent payments even though you have not authorised this. They say you have set up an account when you have not. Their system makes it extremely difficult to make any sort of contact. BUYER BEWARE
By Tom H.