Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
2,400 reviews
BULLYMAKESelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
A monthly dog subscription box featuring durable toys and delicious treats designed for your power chewing dog. www.bullymake.com
BULLYMAKE (bullymake.com) has 2,400 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5.
2,400 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Luna loves the little stuffed animals, although they don't last very long. She likes the rope that came in the box, she likes for me to play tug of war with her and it's something that she hasn't been able to Chew up.
By Thomas
Response from BULLYMAKE· Sep 15, 2025
Hi Thomas - thanks for sharing your experience with us. We are so glad that Luna is loving her Bullymake box!
Our dog ate the ears off the plush immediately. I emailed, company was quick to respond, and we were able to get Rocky something he can’t destroy with their suggestions of toys available.
By Marsha
Response from BULLYMAKE· Sep 15, 2025
Hi Marsha - thanks for sharing your experience with us. We are happy to help you and Rocky have the best experience possible with Bullymake!
Played hard with all the toys and drools for the treats 🥰
By Kim B.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Sep 15, 2025
Hi Kim - we are so glad your pup is a fan! Thanks for taking the time to leave a review with us.
My pups love the toys and haven't destroyed them yet! Two of my dogs loved all the treats, but my Frenchie only liked the one.... but she is pretty boujee.
By Stephanie K.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Sep 15, 2025
Hi Stephanie - thanks for sharing your experience! We are happy to hear your pups are enjoying their deliveries so far.
I would really like the chance to pick the tops for my pup. However they have enjoyed every moment of this experience.
By Daria B.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Sep 15, 2025
Hi Daria - thanks for sharing your experience and we are glad to hear that your pups are enjoying their deliveries. If you ever want to select a special toy separately from your regular subscription, our Bullymake Shop allows for individual purchase and selection of the perfect toy for your pup! Just reach out to our service team via email or chat on our website if you would like assistance.
Reason for a 3 is I am guessing the free toy you just throw whatever in. I let my dog (puppy) chew on the squeaky plush dog but only when we were watching. He had the ear off working 5 min and must have swallowed. Our bad for letting him try it. We just spent $4200 on a vet bill for a Kong toy getting in his gut. So it scared me but it was just a tiny ear. So when we say we only want Nylon don’t send a free stuffy.
By megan
Response from BULLYMAKE· Sep 15, 2025
Hi Megan - thanks for sharing your experience with us. If you are able to reply to the Trustpilot request for information, our team can verify that you have Nylon only on your account to prevent future plush shipments. Our team is here to help make your experience the best it possibly can be - we are just an email or chat away!
The box we ordered didn't contain anything we ordered.. the supposed indestructible toy is in a heaping pile of poop in our back yard .. what a waste of $50.. GARBAGE !!
By Spec D.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Sep 15, 2025
Hello - we are sorry to hear that you did not have a great experience with your Bullymake box. Our team is dedicated to supporting the best possible experience for the pets and pet parents we serve and work hard to partner with pet parents to customize boxes with toy types that work best for your pup. Our team would appreciate the opportunity to learn more about your experience and hopefully make it right. If you are amenable, please reply to our request for more information via TrustPilot and a supervisor will connect directly with you via email to learn more.
My dogs loved there new toy and there treats
By Jeremy L.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Sep 15, 2025
Hi Jeremy - thanks for sharing your experience with us. We are so glad to hear that your pup is a fan!
