Sunday, November 8, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
2,400 reviews
BULLYMAKESelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
A monthly dog subscription box featuring durable toys and delicious treats designed for your power chewing dog. www.bullymake.com
BULLYMAKE (bullymake.com) has 2,400 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5.
2,400 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Our dog LOVES his toy box! Not only does he know what it means when that orange box shows up on the front porch - But since starting, he no longer has to be a kennel when we leave the house - Yay Kapone !!! He keeps himself busy with all his Bullymake Toys !!
By Jaymie L.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Dec 15, 2025
Hi Jaymie - we love that your pup loves Bullymake! Thanks for taking the time to leave a review with us.
my dog didn't chew through anything!!1210
By Patty B.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Dec 15, 2025
Hi Patty - thanks for sharing your experience with us. We are glad to hear our tough toys are a good match for your pup!
Our 8 month old puppy Dale has been getting his box for the past few months now, he gets excited as soon as he sees the mailman pull the box out of his truck and cant wait to open it! The toys and the treats are wonderful, he absolutely loves them. The only reason I didn't give a 5 star review is only for the reason that some of the plush toys aren't made as well as others. Dales "taco" lasted him several months compared to the one day the football guy made it. We do enjoy the opinions for changing up the toys, we switch to the rope toys every other box or so for him. But Dale really enjoys his plush toys and his rubber chewers, its a 50/50 on his pink pig and the red love bug. Overall, it has been a great choice for him..helping to keep Dale busy and out of trouble. :)
By Toshahotmail.com
Response from BULLYMAKE· Dec 14, 2025
Hello - we are so glad to hear that Dale is loving his boxes so far! If there is anything that our team can do to maximize your experience with your subscription, please don't hesitate to reach out to our support team via email or chat on our website!
Dogs love it and I like that it is made in the usa.
By MaryAnne M.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Dec 14, 2025
Hi MaryAnne - we are so glad you and your pups are fans! Thanks for sharing your experience with us.
These are the only toys that have lasted more than an hour with my dog. He loves getting new toys and treats each month. He didn't like the rubber toys so I just went in and changed it on his subscription page, it was simple to find and change.
By Amanda
Response from BULLYMAKE· Dec 14, 2025
Hi Amanda - we are glad to hear your pup has met his match in our tough toys! Thanks for taking the time to leave a review with us.
Our 10 year old girl Sif loves her box! The hard chew toys she absolutely loves and the treats are great and I love that they are grain free.
By sarah
Response from BULLYMAKE· Dec 13, 2025
Hi Sarah - we are so glad that Sif is enjoying her special deliveries! Thanks for sharing your experience with us.
I would love to customize my order. We are learning that there are certain toys & treats that our pup does not prefer. Please let me know how to do that!
By Dana
Response from BULLYMAKE· Dec 13, 2025
Hi Dana, thanks for reaching out and we are excited for you to get the most out of your subscription via customization. There are two ways to accomplish this. The first is by logging into you account online and hand selecting the toys for your next box and inputting your preferences. Or, if you would prefer, you can also simply reach out to our service team via email or chat on our website to assist with any changes!
The nylon toys were too tough and caused bleeding. Also and the biggest point of contention is the fact that it took 3 attempts to cancel my subscription due to the bleeding issue and they kept charging me said they would fix it. Eventually I finally got someone from customer service willing to do their job. Spent $30 and got it cancelled early
By Kirsten M.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Dec 13, 2025
Hi Kirsten - we are very sorry to hear of your experience as the service you describe is not what we strive for at Bullymake. If you are amenable, our service leadership team would appreciate the opportunity to learn more about your experience to ensure we are doing all we can to live up to our promise of delivering excellence to pets and pet parents. If you are willing, please respond to our Trust Pilot request for information and a supervisor will be in contact with you directly via email. Thank you.
