Great Company
5 + stars! Love these "beware of" (schnauzer), (attack duck), (attack rabbit), etc. Quality products, good communications, and fast shipping. Thanks!
By Code
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
529 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Pet Supplies online with same-day order processing and shipping. Shop for supplies for dogs, cats, birds, fish, small animals and other pets. Compare our pet supply prices.
ArcataPet.com (arcatapet.com) has 529 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
529 approved reviews, newest moderated first
5 + stars! Love these "beware of" (schnauzer), (attack duck), (attack rabbit), etc. Quality products, good communications, and fast shipping. Thanks!
By Code
Tag silencers. They were fine as advertised. They turned out to be small for my cat's tags but used them for another pet.
By Barbara
Quick shipping, easy to order, high quality mice that my cats love!!
By Thea
My experience with Arcata Pet was perfect in all respects including shipping. My experience with FedEx Ground receiving this product was imperfect but delivery was successfully achieved -- 3 days later than promised.
By Phred
They had the best price on the multi dog leash I was looking for and it arrived at my house the next day! I do live in California where they are also located but I was very impressed with how quickly the leash arrived. They must have had it in the mail within an hour of my placing the order. I will be ordering from the next time I need something for one of my many pets.
By Sarah F.
I got the product I was looking for after searching high and low for it. The processing and delivery was prompt and the cost was reasonable. I will definitely shop here again. Thank you ArcataPet.com!
By Melody M.
I was looking for a pewter labrador keychain and found one on the ArcataPet website. However, they were out of stock...The message said that they would email me when one came in. I must admit I was skeptical on that one...companies get busy and it wasn't even a $10.00 purchase. But much to my surprise, Chris at ArcataPet DID!!! And I bought it immediately!! It arrived in 2 days. Excellent Service, excellent company - I will buy from them again!
By Linda
Due to the preference of my bird, I always have to place a tailored order each time, and it's always handled fast and efficiently. I wish more companies handled their business like ArcataPet.com.
By Kim Cami C.