Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
21 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
5-Star Insurance is located in St. Petersburg and serves the whole state of Florida by providing affordable auto insurance including SR22 and FR44 policies.Whether you are looking for full coverage or state minimum, liability only, we provide the cheapest car insurance rate in Florida. Our reviews speak for themselves. Contact us today to get affordable auto insurance with 5 Star experience!
5-Star Insurance (5starinsurance.com) has 21 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
21 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Evan was extremely knowledgeable and helpful with my situation. I’ve talked to several agents and nobody was able to help me until I called 5-star. It was quick and easy and Evan was very patient with me through the whole process
By Kris M.
Even was not only knowledgeable about insurance, but he was, helpful, friendly, and understood my situation.
By Kurt M.
Evan was very helpful and made it seem effortless. Giving me the best quote possible with quick and easy sign up!!
By Shawn S.
Response from 5-Star Insurance· Oct 27, 2025
Thank you! I’m so glad we could make the process quick and easy for you and find a great rate. Really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience!
Evan made it super easy for me to find affordable and accessible insurance. After being suspended for financial reasons they didnt hesitate for a second or treat me any different. I really appreciate this company and helping me get back on the road safe and sound! 5 stars across the board.
By Victoria S.
Response from 5-Star Insurance· Oct 23, 2025
Thank you so much for sharing that! I’m really glad we could help you get back on the road without any hassle. We appreciate the kind words and your trust in 5-Star Insurance!
Can’t say enough good things about Evan Marcotte and his agency, 5-Star Insurance! So sincerely impressed by how thoroughly responsive Evan was/is and how he worked so diligently for my husband and I in our search for a more competitive auto insurance policy. He spoke with us at length on the phone, shared his expert advice and insight and answered every and all questions we had. He and his administrative assistant are truly top notch in every way! I am going to recommend Evan and 5-Star to everyone I know for their auto insurance needs. (His company’s name is 5-Star, and is truly deserving of a 10 star review on any survey there would be. They are that good!)
By Lisa L.
Response from 5-Star Insurance· Oct 23, 2025
Thank you so much for such a thoughtful review! I truly appreciate the kind words and the trust you and your husband placed in us. It was a pleasure helping you both, and I’m so glad we could find the right coverage. Your recommendation means a lot to our whole team!
Great experience. I have a rather complicated history and needed special extra coverage insurance and Evan Marcotte was awesome. Super knowledgeable, no B.S, very friendly and found me the best price by far. Thanks man
By Robert W.
Response from 5-Star Insurance· Oct 17, 2025
Thank you for the great review! I’m really glad we could make the process simple and find the right coverage for your situation. I appreciate the trust and kind words!
Evan has been awesome with my experience shopping for insurance. I'd greatly recommend his service or anyone at 5 star insurance
By King royce P.
Response from 5-Star Insurance· Oct 17, 2025
Thank you so much! I’m happy to hear you had a great experience and truly appreciate the recommendation. It’s been a pleasure helping you with your insurance needs!
Evan is awesome and he got me the best price after i called several different places! Highly recommend
By Maria W.
Response from 5-Star Insurance· Oct 14, 2025
Thank you so much! I’m glad we could find you the best price and make the process easy. I really appreciate the recommendation!
