Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
633 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Wild Idea Buffalo is unlike any other meat company. We began with a vision of actually improving the eco-system of the Great Plains. Our buffalo are raised on the wide open spaces of South Dakota where they eat only the native grasses beneath their feet. They spend their whole lives roaming freely on thousands of acres, and never see a feedlot or slaughterhouse. The result is better lives for the bison, the restoration of over 100,000 acres of the prairie, and sweet, delicious red meat that is actually good for you. Not such a wild idea after all!
Wild Idea Buffalo Co (wildideabuffalo.com) has 633 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
Showing 536 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Arrived frozen solid, :) Is tender in the eating and enjoyable taste. I am giving a steak to a good friend I owe good favors back. I appreciate the value of wholesome foods in which this grass fed bison falls. Psychologically it is fun to know I am eating as purely as the Indians, :D
By Lyn K.
Last week I received my order of buffalo steaks, even though I have a few left in the freezer. Perish the thought of running out! I shop the sales and take advantage of FREE SHIPPING! Ordering is easy, shipping is prompt.
By JANE S.
My shipment was sent frozen and on time. I tried the marinade for flank steak from Eating Well Magazine After 4 hours in marinade barbecued over Mesquite wood. Results fantastic, juicy delicious dinner!! Will order again!
By Barbara H.
Products well packaged; still frozen upon reaching destination (CA). Excellent product choices. I Always try to avoid "shipping costs" Am aware of your "bundle" policy with "Free Shipping" .. I Like it !! How about adding another "Free Shipping" policy once a client has spent a certain amount of money within a given period of time ? Well, maybe it's just better to let sleeping Buffalo Lie ... Overall "Thumbs Up" !!! Thanks
By Walt H.
I'm yet to order anything from Wild Idea that my family and myself haven't loved.
By Justin E.
My Dad and his wife both read "Buffalo for the Broken Heart" and decided they wanted to try naturally raised buffalo (until just a few years ago, Dad was a subsistence hunter, processed the meat himself, and always had venison in the freezer, and I think he misses that). As I needed a gift for Dad's birthday, I researched where I could get him some buffalo meat from animals that were raised in their natural environment, and without antibiotics and steroids, etc. As I hadn't read the book myself, had only heard about it from Dad and Lu, and didn't even know its title, I didn't know at the time that this was the author's retail site. But I liked what I found on the site as far as how the animals were raised and how the meat was processed, and I liked the selection available. Ordering was easy. The package arrived exactly when it said it would and was packaged so that it was still frozen, which was a good thing, as the weather was extremely hot when it was delivered. Dad and Lu were thrilled to get to try meat from the Wild Idea Buffalo Co. (and I was happy that I had, albeit unknowingly, ended up selecting to order from the place they had read about!). They are raving about how delicious their buffalo meals have been. Thanks for helping me give Dad a great birthday present - you are now my official go-to place for Dad's future gifts!
By dlw
I was amazed at how quickly I received the stew meat I ordered. Cooked it up the other day - and soooo good!!! Freezing it for Swedish visitors the end of Sept.! Really good price on their meats and lots of variety in cuts. Researched other websites, and this is the BEST - all-around!
By Elaine M.
Very fast service and a great product the dogs love it Would like to be able to get in larger sized packages too.
By Hallie H.
