Brandon is the best!
Brandon is the best! He kept me posted throughout the process, step by step! He is honest and trustworthy, and his prices are very fair! Thank you Brandon! It was a pleasure doing business with you!
By Joan
Tuesday, November 10, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses

The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
174 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
The Old School Game Vault is a nationwide mail-in retro video game buyer and online store that has helped gamers, collectors, and families sell their old games and consoles since 2008. With an A+ BBB rating and more than 22,000 titles in its buying database, OSGV is a trusted way to turn retro games into cash.Founded by Brandon Perton, who grew up playing the original Nintendo NES, we buy games, consoles, and accessories for Nintendo, Sega, PlayStation, Xbox, Atari, and handheld systems. Customers build an order online, ship their items, and receive cash instead of store credit. Orders over $100 get a free prepaid shipping label, and payment is issued within 3 to 4 business days after we receive and process the order.Our online store sells tested, authentic games and consoles, with photos of the exact item customers will receive, including its condition and any flaws.Brandon also shares his experience through game reviews, counterfeit identification articles, and videos showing how our buying service works. We are BBB Accredited with an A+ rating.
The Old School Game Vault (theoldschoolgamevault.com) has 174 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
Showing 166 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Brandon is the best! He kept me posted throughout the process, step by step! He is honest and trustworthy, and his prices are very fair! Thank you Brandon! It was a pleasure doing business with you!
By Joan
Fair pricing with speedy payment!
By Steve K.
One of the best shopping/selling experiences I have ever had. Highly recommend.
By customer
Easy to use website and they do a great job keeping you informed at all steps of the process.
By TMag1234
Quick, easy, very responsive service!
By Carli
Fair prices and good customer service! Loved working with this company.
By Laurie
Awesome! Awesome experience! I am cleaning out my apartment and found a bunch of old games that I was worried that would need to go into a landfill. I thought about Ebay etc. but a bunch of sites that I found are hard to use. I came across "The Old School Game Vault" and I have to say my experience was wonderful. I checked the games on the site and found the corresponding price - mailed the games back and that was it. Quick and easy. I would surely use this site again in the future, it was really great!!!
By Moe M.
The process was nice and easy, there were offers for games that I didn't see anywhere else, and the guidelines for shipping and how the games are evaluated were straight to the point. I would definitely recommend and come here again.
By Philip M.