Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
52 reviews
SurprisechestSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
NOW FREE SHIPPING! Set sail for instant fun. Captain Mystery packed this chest with at least 24 individually wrapped surprises, each one a spark for your party, game night, or gift exchange. No two chests are the same. Your chest arrives gift ready in our signature full color SurpriseChest box that looks like real treasure.Perfect for:Birthdays and office shenanigansWhite elephant, reverse white elephant, or gift rouletteFamily game night, dorm hangouts, holiday chaosFilled with:Lost MailUnclaimed packagesUndeliverable mailReturnsWho knows whatWhat's Inside?Each chest is a true mystery, even to us. We do not open or pre-sort the individual packages. All items are wrapped as received. Actual contents vary, and may include:Undeliverable packagesUnclaimed packagesOverstock productsCustomer returnsCancelled ordersMost items arrive in their original or shipper packaging. Some packages may show box or label wear. That unpredictability is part of the fun.
Surprisechest (surprisechest.com) has 52 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
Showing 37 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
I am up to I believe buying 8 boxes . I plan on buying another one soon I think. I do love you guys. I have made some videos and have tagged you in them. I love the variety and the surprises. My daughter is visiting from Australia, and I was going to get her a box.
By Debra B.
I love being surprised with things I needed......there is plenty of pks for the whole family.....and what I don't use, I give to the salvation army...win win.......thank you so much for the discount for being a specialcustomer........love Liz
By elizabeth L.
I love the way it boxed, how it comes so securely tapes. I love the surprise of all the packages. I love that it arrives so quickly.
By Shannon H.
Fun for family always something for everyone 💗
By Francis P.
Absolutely love them! Never felt like i was being cheated like other companies! Will continue to purchase from them!
By CHRISTINE Q.
Love the packing and pleased with products
By Victoria Z.
Great variety of soft packages and boxes. Box was worth more than I paid. Ordered twice and enjoyed both. Will be ordering again. Since it's mail, you can't predict what you'll get. Enjoyed the mystery of never knowing what you'll get!
By RobinC
I have ordered mystery boxes from numerous different companies, the only one I keep returning to is surprise chest. It is the best, always worth way more than what you pay for it! I have turned a lot of my friends on to surprise chest. I wouldn't say this if it wasn't true believe me, look at my reviews on a couple of the other sites LOL
By Mary B.
