Tuesday, November 10, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Bad
174 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Shirtsinstyle is listed under Clothing & Underwear in Buffalo, New York.
Shirtsinstyle (shirtsinstyle.com) has 174 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 1.1 out of 5.
Showing 167 reviews with 1 star · Clear filters
Gave a 1 because 0 is not an option. Shirts I got were all undersized. Company said shirts would have to be shipped back to China so return and refund were not options. They offered 15% of next order. Why would I want to order more undersized shirts, especially if I have to pay for them? Very bad customer service consisting of robo scripted emails. I highly recommend not ordering from this company.
By Thomas M.
I ordered a large shirt which was way to small and it took 2 weeks to arrive. In order to return it to China, you have to pay the shipping. I would highly recommend NOT buying from this company.
By Mark H.
The items received were not as shown in the advertising photographs. I have emailed this company four times to express my disappointment, and request a refund. Other than an automated standard reply acknowledging my first email, they have not taken any action whatsoever by completely ignoring me. I would further add that the pricing shown on their website purported to be in New Zealand dollars, yet the payment taken from my account was in US dollars, a significant uplift. I believe this company to be inherently dishonest!
By allbrightglobe.net.nz
This company only shipped after I disputed the charge with the CC company. Then I received the shirts and they were very small. Tried to return, and got an address in CHINA to return to. Shipping through USPS was over $30. I would never deal with this unethecial company unless you just need to get RIPPED OFF!!!!!!!!!
By Mark B.
I ordered Judy Blue Jeans and what I did get came straight from China and we're not Judy Blue they were cheap and then I could not return. You do not get what you wanted
By JJ A.
Don’t shop with this company! Not reliable they take forever to send your item then when you try to return it due to the fact that it IS NOT the item you ordered they give the customer the run around using everything possible so you can’t return the item
By Linda M.
This co. Is a total scam. Ordered a pair of Judy Blues Jean's paid $48.94 and got a pair of Jean's that the threads on the Jean's where not even cut on the seams that is how fast they are shipping this .50 cents piece of material to people...please save your money and the trouble of trying to get it back...DON'T ORDER FROM THIS COMPAY!
By Denise K.
A complete mistake dealing with these thieves. Avoid! The craftmanship is poor and the size is completely wrong. Labeled XL but is like a Medium. Return policy is that it must be returned to China which costs more than the shirt. I am notifying the Attorney General.
By Steve B.
