Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
241 reviews
Proper Insurance ServicesSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Proper Insurance is the Nation’s leading vacation rental insurance provider, with over 100,000 policies written in all 50 states. They’ve custom penned the most comprehensive policy on the market, offering unmatched protection for your property, income, host liability, amenity liability (bikes, kayaks, hot tubs, etc.), theft, vandalism, bed bugs, and more. They even cover SQUATTERS!
Proper Insurance Services (proper.insure) has 241 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.
Showing 218 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Taylor Stults gave me fantastic service as I am pleased to purchase insurance through Proper. Taylor was very responsive and responded in a fast manner. I am eager to work with Taylor in the future!
By Carter L.
Harold Helt of Proper Insurance was my adjuster for a property and loss of business income claim. He contacted me within 24 hours of my initial report of the loss, provided clear information on how to proceed, and processed my report and receipts without delay. All while maintaining regular communication with me about the status of the claim. Excellent service, excellent communication. I'm very happy with my Proper Insurance policy, and have been a client for years. Thanks again.
By John B.
Mathew was amazing. The team at proper responded quickly and efficiently during a time of great stress. They reimbursed the expenses within 2 weeks of filing my claim. I'm so happy with their service.
By Shelyna R.
Payton Voss was extremely helpful and very responsive . With this being my first STR I did not know what to expect from the insurance side. Payton took the time to answer all of my questions and made the process super simple. Highly recommend Payton and Proper!
By Jeremy G.
Reported damage with pictures. They told me what to expect with deductibles per contract. Selected contractor I wanted to do business with. The will be sending a check via ACH to my account
By Dan M.
We were having absolutely no luck getting insured for our short-term rental in Florida. I called Mike Wolf with Proper and he was able to give me a quote in no time. I am so glad we found Proper because I am now confident that we have the correct type of insurance for our vacation rental!
By Meredith Patton W.
Great customer service, very on point and upfront about the cost. Looking forward to a long healthy relationship with this company.
By Triple C H.
Taylor Stults was great to work with! She provided a quote very quickly and answered all the questions I had over the phone. It's great when you can get ahold of someone at an insurance company without going through 20 prompts on an automated system and holding for 10 minutes. The quote covers everything I need for our STR and will allow me to sleep well at night! Great experience!
By JACE Property Group, L.
