Great Experience!
Fast shipping, Island Surf keeps you updated throughout the entire shipping process. Love, love, love the product! Will definitely shop at Island Surf again.
By Kerry
Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses

The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
784 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Islanders Coastal Outfitter is your source for surf & outdoor women's and men's shoes, accessories, apparel and gear. Our brands include Hari Mari, Rainbow, Reef, Olukai, UGG, KAVU and many others. We are lucky to call the beach our home since 1980.
Islanders Outfitter (islandersoutfitter.com) has 784 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.
Showing 680 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Fast shipping, Island Surf keeps you updated throughout the entire shipping process. Love, love, love the product! Will definitely shop at Island Surf again.
By Kerry
Awesome deal!
By Michael
My friend turned me on to rainbow double stacked sandals and I have been ordering them ever since! They are comfortable, have much arch support and never break! Oh yeah, they look great too!!!
By Little
Good selection and fast shipping. I am very happy with my order and will order from here again.
By Kylie E.
Even though I chose standard delivery, my order arrived within 3 business days! Yay!
By Jennifer
Response from Islanders Outfitter· Oct 19, 2016
Aloha! Thank you for your time to review our service!
Ordering from a new online vendor can sometimes be an adventure. I'm happy to say that the staff at Island Surf exceeded all expectations and turned what most would consider an inconvenience into a breezy transaction. After my initial order was placed they informed me that the sandals I ordered were on back order. With a wedding in (3) weeks I was quite nervous that they would come in. Not only did the associate get with the buyer, have these added to an existing PO, she also followed up with multiple phone calls as she said she would (a rarity nowadays). In addition to keeping me well informed along the ways I was also given an unexpected 10% discount for my "trouble". Can't say enough about Island Surf and their customer service... says a lot about their company, in my opinion. Thanks again for all your help AND having the lowest price on the web. I'll be back.
By Brickford F.
I got the best deal and service ever from you on my Patagonia sweater
By Laura S.
I absolutely love my Patagonia pullover! The shipping was very fast! I would highly recommend this website to anyone
By Shayna H.