GameBananaReviews of gamebanana.com

I had a disappointing and frustrating experience with GameBanana. I downloaded a mod for The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild that was explicitly titled and described as CEMU/Wii U compatible (Mod ID: 526522, ‘Textures Full HD pack for CEMU’). After taking over 7 hours to download, i discovered that the contents of the pack were not compatible with CEMU at all, lacking files essential for installation (such as ‘rules.txt’ or the ‘content/’ folder), and in fact being usable only for Switch emulators such as Yuzu/Ryujinx. I decided to write a negative review on the mod page to warn other users and to point out the discrepancy between the description and the actual content. My review was based on facts, detailing the specific compatibility problem and time lost. Surprisingly, this review was removed by GameBanana moderation with the reason ‘R.17: Nonsense’, without any clarification or opportunity for meaningful direct appeal. I find it unacceptable that a factual and helpful review, intended to prevent other users from running into the same misleading compatibility problem, is labeled as ‘nonsense’ and removed. This undermines confidence in the accuracy of mod descriptions on the platform and the review moderation process, preventing users from having complete and reliable information. I hope GameBanana will review its moderation policies and ensure greater accuracy in mod descriptions to prevent future disappointment for users.

I recently logged back in after 1-3 years to see almost everything I submitted trashed/deleted without any valid reason. I re-read the rules and everything I submitted followed the site's extremely strict rules. I requested an untrash but got completely ignored. The only good thing about this site is the customizability. I do not recommend.

I just uploaded an mod and then it just dissapeared im too lazy to go onmy laptop to repost my sonic mania mod

After requesting the deletion of my fnf mods from my old scrubbed accounts I got permanent ban for "Abuse of the site's Scrubber feature". Rules listed for the ban reason are R.13 "Multiple accounts per member are not allowed." and R.20 "Content may be withheld or trashed and members gagged or banned at the sole discretion of top level site admins.". I made 4 appeals where I explained that I was scrubbing my accounts only if I have no use for this platform and that I was creating new account to use platform again. There is no option for full deletion of the account available. I also mentioned that if admins understand my position, want me to continue upload new updates for my mod without any problems and my future mistakes they should unban me or delete this banned account if they cannot accept my appeal. They denied my appeal and rejected both options. They just illegally keep my information on their site without letting users like me to fully manage their privacy. Why would they even add option for ban appeal if this option does nothing special? Why I couldn't and still can't access my scrubbed accounts to avoid such situations? Why account deletion for long inactivity and users' willing isn't a thing? This is a really deep mystery. My banned account's ID number: 2870771 My previous scrubbed accounts' ID numbers: 1825573 and 2121707

This site is a joke. Me and my brother both use gamebanana, so we obviously use two separate accounts. Suddenly I got banned for "having multiple accounts". Why? Because we're on the same IP address. When I submitted a ban appeal, they didn't even respond. I really hope there will be a new competitor against Gamebanana and Nexus soon, because both sites have terrible support.

I've been using GB since it was created. It wasn't all that bad at first, but in the recent years, it's gone to complete crap and and the moderation is even worse than that.

Completely Terrible. My mod was trashed because it was labeled under nonsense, even though I've worked on it for 6 months, and none of the term "nonsense" is present in this mod.

Give us new none Liberal modding websites, no seriously this isn't funny, we need freedom of expression within the modding community, Etika skin was banned without reason, I miss it so much cause he was such a chad, joke skins like Osama is also banned including Gandy like what the heck???