A wonderful surprise
A wonderful surprise for my husband. He loved it. It is not the best chocolate but in the end, it wasn't the most important for me. Well packaged and delivered on time. Very satisfied
By HP
Tuesday, November 10, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
518 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Anonymously mail a bag of dicks with the message "EAT A BAG OF DICKS".
Dicks By Mail (dicksbymail.com) has 518 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
Showing 416 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
A wonderful surprise for my husband. He loved it. It is not the best chocolate but in the end, it wasn't the most important for me. Well packaged and delivered on time. Very satisfied
By HP
I've sent a few d*cks in my day. This company is the best to go with. Always on time, always shipped and packaged great. Everyone loves their d*cks. Who doesn't want an anonymous d*ck in their box????
By Kali
This company was awesome. I ordered a cup and I ordered the wrong one. I honestly think it was my fault. I emailed this company and asked what we could do so I could get the one I wanted and they sent me the one I wanted and let me keep the other one. That's the kindest any company has been to me. So cool!!!
By Stevie M.
Great customer service. Very honorable reliable and dependable
By Nick O.
I had placed an order of eat @$!$ to my ex. I realized I probably shouldn't have done that because he cant take a joke. I emailed dicksbymail n they were so cool and understanding. They cancelled my order with no problems! Im def going to order again but this time I'm sending it to my bestie. She can take a joke! Thank you for being so awesome!!
By Amber C.
Love this place! Sent a couple gags to some people. Had to put the brakes on an order, sent an email with a change of address. I was emailed back promptly with awesome customer service! Will order again!
By Tony
Customer service for this site is insane. I accidently left my phone number on an order (like an idiot) and emailed them to cancel the order before it shipped. I received a response lightning quick and the order was canceled. If that wasn't awesome enough, the staff are very friendly and efficient. They won't waste your time.
By burrito I.
Great customer service the Address was incomplete on my part I emailed them the correct Address and they responded the next business day with with a new confirmation number and re shipped my item same day
By mathew C.