Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
523 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Comp-Tac® Holsters is devoted to designing and manufacturing the highest quality concealed carry, competition, and tactical holsters on the market. We build with the customer in mind, ensuring fast delivery times, excellent quality, competitive pricing, and attentive customer service to support our community. We take each step of our manufacturing process very seriously, so we fit check every single holster with the actual firearm that it is designed for before it leaves our factory. Comp-Tac® products are user-driven and are designed based on the operational experiences of a wide variety of end users, to include military and law enforcement personnel. In 2018, High Speed Gear® purchased the Comp-Tac® brand and we are proud to be part of the High Speed Gear Products Group. Our holsters work seamlessly with HSGI® and together, our 2 brands offer exceptional quality and innovation that our customers trust and rely on.
Comp-Tac Holsters (comp-tac.com) has 523 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
Showing 41 reviews with 4 stars · Clear filters
Great product. Definitely recommend. High quality kydex, multiple accessories included providing several holstering options. However, Insufficient assembly instructions plus no online YouTube video to reference for assembly are reason for one star deduction. Headsup to others, the holster did not have a sufficient cut out to accommodate Berreta’s extended magazine release causing some manual cutout rework by me to stop recurring magazine ejection upon reholsering.
By NorCal S.
I would really like to give 5stars because I love my holster and refuse to use safariland due to the slow draw. My only knock is for lvl 3 duty on Walther pdp, it does not have optic hood option to keep my optic clean as I work in a dusty environment. If I could send it in to get a hood for my optic it would be perfect.
By Derick H.
Great holster and impressed with how quick the process was!! Belt attachment is a little bulky but could be changed out. Overall very happy!!
By Greg S.
Great holster. Exactly what I was looking for. At first, I gave 3 stars because I ordered the QD add on but did not originally seem compatible with this configuration. I can still use it on another holster. I’d have to remove thumb release or find a block that brings it out further in order to utilize QD attachment. If it is compatible in some way, there are no instructions with it or online. Update: after watching the video below I was able to make it work. From the factory it seems it was installed backwards. Excellent customer service.
By Matthew J.
Response from Comp-Tac Holsters· Apr 23, 2024
Thank you for your review, glad the holster is working out for you! This video might help with the SQR installation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zH4xJUrP6HQ&t=2s
I love your holsters. I keep buying and upgrading them.
By Gregory W.
Love the infidel ultra and wanted the same comfortable fit with the easy on/off convenience for my latest EDC. They didn't make it for the new gun with an optical sight (reason for 4 stars), but I was able to modify their standard holster to fit. I understand they can't make a holster for every pistol, but was happy I could make one work.
By Jim S.
Comp-Tac was great, the postal service was very slow.
By Glen W.
easy to find a holster, and easy to buy on line, and quick shipment however, had to ream out the holes some difficult to remove factory installed screws, seemed like they were glued
By LEONARD F.
