Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
2,400 reviews
BULLYMAKESelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
A monthly dog subscription box featuring durable toys and delicious treats designed for your power chewing dog. www.bullymake.com
BULLYMAKE (bullymake.com) has 2,400 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5.
Showing 126 reviews with 3 stars · Clear filters
More attractive German shepherd toys that are possessive over balls
By Janet Y.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jan 5, 2026
Hi Janet - thanks for sharing your experience and your feedback. Our design team is always looking for new ways to improve and expand our toy selection and we appreciate you taking the time to share!
I have mixed feelings about my Bullymake experience. First, the company provides high-quality snacks and toys with great shipping. However, for the price one pays for the subscription, the choices and options are pretty limited, especially for the toys, which was the main reason I took out the subscription. During my 3-month subscription, I received the same indestructible-type toy that my dog enjoys, but I would have liked to see a little more variety. Yes, you can select from different toy options identified as "rope", "ballistic", "nylon", and "rubber", but the options within those categories are pretty limited. If you choose to use "snacks" as an option, you'll get 2-3 small bags of treats. Again, nice, but limited options. I felt that 3 months gave me plenty of time to evaluate the program fairly. For the price that I paid and the options that my dogs received, I'm not going to renew my subscription.
By Tim S.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jan 5, 2026
Hi Tim - we appreciate you taking the time to provide us with your candid feedback. It is honest and actionable suggestions and feedback like yours that really help us continue to grow our offerings and serve our pet parents in the best way possible. Our team would love to learn a bit more regarding your experience. If you are willing, please reply to our Trustpilot request for information and a team member will be in touch via email.
Our puppy loves your treats and indestructible toys. Unfortunately though I never received the blue remote control toy I ordered extra and paid for. Otherwise, I would've given you 5 stars. How do I get the toy I paid for?
By BonBon
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jan 4, 2026
Hello - thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We are glad your puppy is enjoying the toys you did receive, we apologize for inadvertently not sending a toy that you expected and are committed to making it right. Our support team can help and can be reached via email or chat on our website. Or, if you prefer, we can connect with you directly via email - simply reply to our Trustpilot request for information.
I really like the quality of the toys but my dog is still able to chew bits and pieces of them off the toys.
By Michelle M.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jan 2, 2026
Hi Michelle - thanks for sharing your experience with us. With pups like yours that have unmatched jaw strength, we recommend our toughest nylon toys for ultimate durability. If you would like to receive a free replacement of a tougher toy to replace the damaged one, simply reach out to our team within 45 days of purchase - we are just an email or chat away!
The size of the toys are quite small and will pose a choking hazard for my dog as he gets bigger.
By Nikki P.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jan 1, 2026
Hi Nikki - thanks for sharing your feedback. Please know that we realize how important it is to allow for customization of your box to work best for your pup. You can manage your upcoming toy preferences for future boxes in your online account. Or if you prefer you can reach out to our support team for assistance - we are just an email or chat away!
Our pup is hit or miss with her new toys. She was excited when she first got them, and hasn't looked at them since😒. Hope that changes since Im locked in for 12 months
By Penny B.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Dec 29, 2025
Hi Penny - we are sorry to hear that your pup is waning interest. We understand that each dog has its own unique play style and some toys may work better than others. If you would like to try some different toy styles, please feel free to reach out to our support team via email or chat on our website to discuss some options. We are happy to help you get the most out of your subscription with us!
I don’t like pull toys poplar is a service dog and isn’t allowed pull toys made of string as they can come unraveled and caught in her intestines the rest of the toys are great
By Renee R.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Dec 27, 2025
Hi Renee - thanks for sharing your experience and feedback with us. At Bullymake we realize that dogs have their own unique play style and some toy materials are a better fit. It is for this reason that we offer box customizations to help pet parents pick the exact toy types they want to receive in their next delivery. To update your preferences, you can log in to your account online or reach out to us via email or chat on our website - we are happy to help!
The ball was ripped apart in two days.
By mel S.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Dec 27, 2025
Hi Mel - we are sorry to hear that your pup got the best of one of our toys. The good news is that if your pup ever comes across a toy that doesn't work for their play style, you can simply reach out to our support team with a photo within 45 days of purchase and our team will send a free replacement toy your way! Reach out via email or chat on our website for assistance or, if you prefer, respond to our Trustpilot request for information and a team member will connect directly with you via email.
