Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
2,400 reviews
BULLYMAKESelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
A monthly dog subscription box featuring durable toys and delicious treats designed for your power chewing dog. www.bullymake.com
BULLYMAKE (bullymake.com) has 2,400 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5.
Showing 476 reviews with 4 stars · Clear filters
She can't tear any of the boys up
By Laqwell G.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Apr 11, 2025
Hi Laqwell - we are glad your pup has found her match in our toy offerings! Thanks for sharing your experience with us.
The drum has been a hit from the Marti Gras pack. She destroyed the other 2 toys
By Dawn S.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Apr 9, 2025
Hi Dawn - we are glad to hear that the drum toy has been a favorite in your household. From what you shared above, it doesn't sound like the other two toys were the best fit for your pup's unique play style, which is exactly why we offer customization of toy types in future boxes along with our toy replacement guarantee! Please reach out to our team via email or chat and we would be happy to suggest some toy types that might be a better fit and get a replacement in the works for you.
The mixture of tough toys and semi-tough toys made for a great time. The snacks were delicious!
By Jill B.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Apr 7, 2025
Hi Jill - thanks for sharing your experience. We are so happy to hear that LuLu loves her Bullymake goodies!
Our pup loved the treats and toys, but there was some destruction of one of the toys. So maybe not entirely indestructible….but overall great experience!
By Geanean
Response from BULLYMAKE· Apr 7, 2025
Hello Geanean - we are happy to hear that your pup enjoyed our treats and toys! Each dog definitely has their own unique play style and it sounds like your pup may fall into our tough chewer category of which rubber or nylon toys are often the best fit. Our team would be more than happy to support you in customizing your next box for the best experience possible. Simply reach out to us via email or chat!
Wish the treat bags had a little more treats in it! But other than that my dogs love them, and the toys are great!
By paige L.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Apr 7, 2025
Hi Paige - we are glad the toys and treats are a hit for your pups! I would be happy to pass along your suggestion to "supersize" your treat selection to our team, as we are always looking for ways to improve our offerings.
The toys are better than most we have bought. But our dog still chewed thru everything but the hard plastic ones
By Candy P.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Apr 7, 2025
Hi Candy - thanks for taking the time to share your experience. It sounds like your pup definitely falls in the "ultra chewer" category! If you need assistance customizing your future boxes to include more (or all) nylon toys, our team is happy to help. After all, we want each box delivered to provide ultimate enjoyment for your household!
I was a little disappointed when my fur baby was able to tear apart the purple toy that you put a treat in. However she loved getting to explore a whole box of toys just for her.
By Beth
Response from BULLYMAKE· Apr 7, 2025
Hi Beth - thank you for sharing your experience! We know that each dog has their own unique play needs and preferences, which is why we offer our toy replacement guarantee whenever a toy doesn't work out for your pup. If you are looking to find a toy that can stand up to those tough chewers, feel free to reach out to our team for some recommendations on toy types and how to best customize your future boxes for maximum enjoyment. For example, our rubber and nylon toys are built for those pups with an aggressive chewing play style. We are more than happy to help!
The toys were very durable. I just wish there were more to choose from.
By Ciara D.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Apr 4, 2025
Hi Ciara - thanks for sharing your experience and we are glad our toys are a hit in your household. Our team is always looking to improve on our rotating toy selection and welcome feedback from our customers on what you would like to see in future boxes - we will send you a request for information through the Trust Pilot portal if you would like to share more specific feedback. Additionally, our Bullymake shop (https://bullymakeshop.com/) also has toys from past box themes available for purchase if your pup has a past favorite!
