Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
2,400 reviews
BULLYMAKESelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
A monthly dog subscription box featuring durable toys and delicious treats designed for your power chewing dog. www.bullymake.com
BULLYMAKE (bullymake.com) has 2,400 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5.
Showing 476 reviews with 4 stars · Clear filters
First delivery was decent looking forward to the other toys for her !!! Then maybe a 5 star !
By Michael L.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jun 24, 2026
Hi Michael! We are so glad to hear your delivery was a success. We can't wait for you and your pup to see what's in your next box.
Love the toys and so do my pups. But.. the treat ingredients are not our fav although the boys do like it every once in a while.
By Reghan H.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jun 24, 2026
Hi Reghan! Thank you so much for your honest feedback! We’re thrilled to hear that your pups are loving the toys—that’s always our top priority! We also really appreciate you sharing your thoughts on the treats. Every dog has different tastes and dietary preferences, so we completely understand. We’re glad the boys still enjoy them as an occasional snack. If you’d ever like to tailor your subscription more toward toys your pups love most, you can customize your box anytime using the link below: https://bullymake.com/customer_authentication/login?return_to=%2Fapps%2Fsubscriptions%2Fmanage
We got 2 toys that were garden theme a strawberry thats like the kong material and a pea that Nova girl loves and then 2 treats that she goes crazy over. Can’t wait to see what the next box has
By Cece
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jun 24, 2026
Hi Cece! We’re so happy to hear Nova is loving her garden-themed box! The strawberry toy and pea toy sound like the perfect combo, and it’s awesome to know she’s going crazy for the treats, too. We can't wait to keep the fun coming in the next box.
Toys are great and Chloe loves the treats
By Amy M.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jun 24, 2026
Hi Amy! We love hearing that our Bullymake box is bringing joy to Chloe. That's exactly what we strive for. We can't wait to keep the excitement coming in her next box.
my dog loved all his toys. He is very happy with his box for sure. His plushy has lasted him quite a while considering he loves to send a plushy to Valhalla every week. His rubber strawberry is perfect for hiding treats in, his pea is really built for the tough chewer, and he’s been gnawing on his rope since he got it. I would’ve given five stars but I was only suppose to pay 26$CAD for his first box but I paid 46$CAD. So.. points deducted on that, but overall, 46 dollars for the quality of the toys I got is still a good deal.
By Taccarra G.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jun 24, 2026
Hi there! We’re really glad to hear your pup is enjoying the box! It’s great to know the plush toy, rubber strawberry, pea, and rope are all holding up well, even with an enthusiastic chewer. That kind of durability feedback is exactly what we aim for. We also hear your concern about the pricing difference on the first box. That’s understandably frustrating, especially when you were expecting a different introductory rate. If you’d like, our team can take a closer look at your account to confirm what was applied and why the charge landed at $46 CAD instead of $26 CAD. If you are willing, please respond to the request for additional information initiated through Trustpilot, and one of our supervisors will reach out from our leadership team.
My dog loved both toys and the treats
By Anthony C.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jun 12, 2026
Hi Anthony! We love knowing your furry friend enjoyed the toys and treats. We aim to please the pets and pet parents we serve! We can't wait for you to see what is in the next box.
The rope toy was not for my big ol boys, but they made it right! I have some happy pups (4 of them)!
By Monica
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jun 10, 2026
Hi Monica! We’re sorry the rope toy wasn’t the right fit for your big pups, but we’re so glad we could make it right. We know every pup's play style is different, which is why we offer the option to customize your boxes! If our team can help you with anything, feel free to reach out. We will be happy to support you and your pups. https://bullymake.com/pages/contact
The kong is the biggest hit. The other chews got some use. The rope was sadly a flop. More kong like toys please !
By Freerider R.
Response from BULLYMAKE· Jun 10, 2026
Hi there. We appreciate you sharing your feedback. We know that every dog has their own play style preference, which is why we offer the option to customize your pup's box to suit them best. You can customize your box here https://bullymake.com/customer_authentication/login?return_to=%2Fapps%2Fsubscriptions%2Fmanage or by reaching out to our support team!
