The cake looked amazing
The cake looked amazing, it was exactly what I wanted and tasted yummy as well.
By Elizabeth
Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
100 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Cakery is listed under Bakery & Pastry in New York, New York.
Cakery (bakestreet.co) has 100 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5.
Showing 80 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
The cake looked amazing, it was exactly what I wanted and tasted yummy as well.
By Elizabeth
We decided 6 days before our party to get a special cake. We didn't think we would have enough time to get the cake. I found this website and gave it it try! We immediately got a bunch of responses and chose to work with Jenny! Best decision!! She was responsive, had great ideas and just fun to work with! The cake looked amazing and tasted great!!
By Tracy
Kim from CakenIt really really was polite..ontime and her creativity was amazing! Bakestreet really made this happen! Best cake thus far I ordered! Moist and delicious
By Pocah H.
Everyone has been super helpful and have answered all my questions timely. I will definitely use bakestreet again in the future.
By no N.
I loved the choices of styles and prices. The fact that I could hire a local baker was a real plus for me. The communication with the producer was clear The cake arrived on time. It was gorgeous and tasted even better then it looked. Everyone asked for the name of the company
By Natasha
I was connected to bakers right away and got quotes very quickly. All the bakers were very responsive.
By customer
The responses from bakestreet were immediate and helpful- even on a Sunday - which was very reassuring as we were organising this from a different Timezone. The baker got one aspect of the decoration wrong but not disastrous at all.
By Richard J.
Delicious, beautiful cake! As described. Would recommend.
By customer